Adam Devereaux (@wiredsim) header
Adam Devereaux (@wiredsim) profile picture
Joined May 2009
Photo by Adam Devereaux (@wiredsim)Photo by Adam Devereaux (@wiredsim)Photo by Adam Devereaux (@wiredsim)Photo by Adam Devereaux (@wiredsim)Photo by Adam Devereaux (@wiredsim)
Adam Devereaux retweeted
I've long argued that, outside of formally posable questions, thought experiments tend to do more harm than good. And this is why. Note that this experiment is not formally posable, because what must be "written on the paper" is not computationally reducible. There *exists no prestatable set* of possible input / output combinations, because language is neither static nor closed at any level. Many forget this, because linguistic evolution has always occurred over spans not traceable during a single lifetime. And this is where those whose minds are consumed by Analytic Reduction always come up short––they must invariably reduce open processes that cohere under the constraints of emergent continuity to models that close over, and thus render invisible, the actual issue at hand. Which is that the paper, which can't exist, also can't *do* anything. It is not the *kind* of process that *can* do anything. It is not even itself a process; it is a terminus of lower order processes, rendered inert by our own hand, in service our own open-ended telos. This distinction is not trivial. For example, it was the singular point that John Wheeler, one of the most influential physicists of the 20th century, chose to convey to his classes as a frame for their studies. He did so by asking the class to write down every flight-relevant equation they knew on a sheet of paper, then to turn their papers in. At which point he threw the papers in the air and beckoned them to "Fly!". Of course they fell to the ground, inert as ever. And this is the central point––a point humanity will not and cannot address until we remove the Analytic Worm from the memetic depths to which it has burrowed and re-examine its limitations, in light of the accumulated evidence against its primacy as explanatory frame.
Math, of course, cannot be conscious. Let’s assume a human could perfectly write/simulate every output of a 100T parameter LLM on a piece of paper. That system, in itself, is conscious. That system would have to be aware that a human is writing the outputs for it when you ask it. The only entities capable of simulating a self-aware and conscious being are conscious beings. If you place the human and paper in a box and only observe the output of the paper, the system is conscious. However, when you replace the human in the scenario with a computer, people become angry.
6
2
13
805
Adam Devereaux retweeted
149
205
156
2,453
1,073,631
Adam Devereaux retweeted
"You don't see four clusters?"
“It’s totally arbitrary to say there are three clusters here”
295
319
148
9,448
1,800,407
“All progress depends on Unreasonable minds”- so neurodiversity is an evolutionary search to produce the most unreasonable mind that’s still accepted by other humans & can bring consolidation of possibility space search back into the cultural mind or tech tree?
1
84
What is the point of humans? That’s the key question we aren’t asking. Is it to just exist? For example- A job can provide income while simultaneously reducing overall human flourishing. Do we protect that job?
2
79
1. Renewables will shatter the source of nearly all human conflict: energy scarcity. Almost every form of “resource scarcity” has always been a proxy for energy. The fossil age was about extraction and exploitation. Whoever controlled the molecules controlled us all.
1
3
168
2. Renewables flip the model. They are local energy autonomy: scalable, low-skill, adaptable. No gatekeepers. No monopolies on expertise. We are entering the Sand Age: glass and silicon, harvesting photons and electrons instead of burning molecules.
1
2
113
3. Old world: Extract > ship > burn > repeat. Energy was centralized, scarce, tradeable. New world: Harvest flows > store > use. Energy is local, abundant, autonomous. This is the end of scarcity as destiny. The wars for molecules end when energy no longer moves.
78
I know I am on X too long when my feed just turns into slop videos. For some reason that works better than my screen time reminders to get me to put it down…
1
71
Is this an ADHD thing? I feel like my system prompt gets purged frequently. I forget things about myself & lessons I’ve learned only to re-remember them later. Maybe I need a morning system prompt affirmation I read. But some of these things are feelings & hard to put into words.
125
Why are Democrats are Mom coded and Republicans Dad coded? It’s like we now have the dad who promised everything like candy for dinner, but doesn’t actually know how to do shit.. The house is a mess l, we’ve run out of food& Billy doesn’t have his insulin. Moms fault somehow.
1
105
I wonder if finding a partner is supposed to be difficult. At least difficult enough that you don’t wanna bother trying to go through that again so you just stick it out… it all becomes relative tolerances for relationship inadequacy versus how much u dislike the dating process
97
Deepseek is like crack game devs making the best of a game console at the end of its life (like the Last of Us or GT6 on the PS3). Squeezed out amazing results with what they had to work with. But we didn’t stop there. Sony wasn’t doomed. PS4 goes on to sell 117,000,000 units
101
Nature’s harsh truth: Stressed mammals delay reproduction, reabsorb embryos and abandon offspring. Deer, mice, even primates. Modern humans? Amid economic chaos, isolation, and dread, plummeting birth rates may mirror biology’s cold equation: No safety, no future.
57
Crazy how correctly diagnosing your car problem often depends on if you happen to pick the right word out of: rumble, vibration, shake, wobble, shimmy, shudder, jiggle, pulse, bump, rattle or oscillation..
1
46
Ppl complaining about how "many pages" US Laws are don't realize it's a derived property of having a Common Law legal system, It's essentially a "copy-paste" programming model, with minimal use of independent libraries. Each law needs its own functions & relationship definitions
50
Wait is the #dronesnj essentially a panic caused by computational photography because people have come to rely on their phones to zoom in on distance objects and are trying to do so in the dark? This is Bigfoot in the era of “good” cameras being pushed into where they are bad?
54
Right wing and left wing are fundamentally flawed concepts that have run their course. We invent words to describe reality and then try to limit reality by those words. Human political beliefs are high dimensional graphs based on complex life experiences & culture.
60
The blatant stupidity of some online advertising is wild. A coat company saying: “Your not a child, you’re a man. Stop wearing so many layers”. 🤦‍♂️ Or deodorant companies telling you that you “stink everywhere”. Marketers are a Shame on their families & humanity in general.
56
We make up words to describe reality, and then we start to define reality by those words. Words become a lens to see by. Stare through any one lens for too long and it will distort your perceptions.
33