Patrick Donnelly (@bitterwaterblue) header
Patrick Donnelly (@bitterwaterblue) profile picture

Desert advocate. Great Basin Director, @CenterForBioDiv & @CBD_Action_Fund. Not going gentle into that good night. Tweets my own.

The edge of Death Valley, USA
Joined March 2016
Photo by Patrick Donnelly (@bitterwaterblue)Photo by Patrick Donnelly (@bitterwaterblue)Photo by Patrick Donnelly (@bitterwaterblue)Photo by Patrick Donnelly (@bitterwaterblue)Photo by Patrick Donnelly (@bitterwaterblue)Photo by Patrick Donnelly (@bitterwaterblue)Photo by Patrick Donnelly (@bitterwaterblue)Photo by Patrick Donnelly (@bitterwaterblue)Photo by Patrick Donnelly (@bitterwaterblue)Photo by Patrick Donnelly (@bitterwaterblue)
Spoiler alert: bad projects don't get to no without litigation. BAAJA will lock in bad projects.
"This is about getting good projects to yes faster AND bad projects to no faster." - @SenatorHeinrich notes that streamlining permitting is about getting to a definitive agreement faster and with greater certainty on the timeline. Projects that violate clean air, clean water and other substantive environmental laws are still illegal.
13
35
1
139
2,394
Biodiversity... you know, the thing that keeps us all alive, is an "edge case."
Hey, it's me, again. I want to zoom out on BAAJA for a second, because it’s easy to get lost in the weeds & debates about edge cases. I care *a lot* about this bill. Wanted to remind myself why. The status quo is *terrible* for both climate and affordability. We built 888 miles of high-voltage transmission in 2024; we need 5,000 a year. More clean capacity is waiting in interconnection queues than the entire existing grid. Residential power prices are up about a third since 2019. Demand is surging, and bc clean power can’t connect, we're building a bunch of gas. If this current trend continues, gas could supply half of US power by 2040. The administration is using permitting as a weapon to stop wind and solar projects, including ones already approved. And local restrictions on wind and solar now cover twice as much of the country as in 2022. I worked in the White House when we passed the IRA. As @BrianCDeese noted, if we had a bill like this in place first, it would have been game-changing. We invested hundreds of billions to put clean energy on sale, then watched projects get stuck in interconnection queues, permitting delays, and fights over who pays for transmission. The money was not the binding constraint; the ability to build was. Let’s not make the next Democratic administration learn that lesson twice! It's easy to oppose stuff. But BAAJA is a *really, really big deal.* This is the first real federal framework to plan, pay for, and permit big power lines: mandatory planning between regions, clear rules on who pays (based on who benefits), and federal backstop siting that actually works across most of the country. It also ends incumbent utilities’ automatic right to build every new regional line. It will also help actually get projects online, by requiring grid planning and interconnection be done together, and stopping speculative projects clogging the queue. It should protect from political sabotage. Approved projects can’t be yanked for political reasons, and developers can sue if an administration targets a technology like wind for unfair treatment. It's the strongest data center accountability legislation in the country to ensure they pay *more* than the costs they cause and that households don’t foot the bill for AI’s grid upgrades. This is the most important thing Congress can do for clean energy and affordability right now. We can fight about the emissions and affordability modeling about this narrow bill. But the truth is that this is the necessary but insufficient foundation *every future climate and affordability policy will be built on.*
7
31
1
212
4,138
One disaster from BAAJA is it would allow states to carry out ESA Section 7 consultation. This is a duty of the federal government - the point in the process where harm to endangered species is prevented. States should not be responsible for consultation. Many states, especially in the Western US, have a vested interest in moving projects forward, and have openly hostile policies regarding the ESA. Allowing them to conduct consultation jeopardizes endangered species which are threatened by industry.
7
88
4
219
3,832
Patrick Donnelly retweeted
Since both Democrats and Republicans are lying about it, here's what #BAAJA would really do... - have little to no impact on climate - make it easier to build data centers - attack Tribal sovereignty - weaken bedrock environmental laws - barely bring down the cost of energy
7
43
3
71
1,347
Mining has their man. #nvleg
Replying to @NVGOPAssembly
@NVGOPAssembly has elected Assemblyman Rich DeLong as Minority Leader. “Nevadans should not live under a blank check. The mission to win back seats and get out of our current super minority starts today. We intend to win back every seat we lost ." - @Delong4NV
1
2
640
Patrick Donnelly retweeted
Some of my NO BAAJA arguments: • Its undemocratic in its formation • It opens door wider for Trump/Miller actions while closing door to review them later • Curbs access for working class communities to challenge projects • Narrows states’ ability to protect their own waters • Guts the ability to challenge a project on its cumulative effects — THIS IS HUGE • Frees fed agencies to make major decisions without consulting state agencies or even the general public • It smashes any semblance of proper Nation-2-Nation consultation with Tribal Nations. all to the detriment of Mother Earth, our communities and Tribes. And these things are NOT worth the tradeoffs for BAAJA to pass.
10
109
6
249
4,270
Permitting is said like a bad word. Permitting is what gives us clean air & water, wildlife, a liveable planet. Corporations will build whatever makes them the most money regardless of environmental impacts. The point of permitting is to put checks on that. BAAJA eviscerates it.
35
173
14
660
21,547
Patrick Donnelly retweeted
Proud to stand with Food and Water Action and DOZENS of other groups against AI data centers. We’re calling for a federal moratorium. Our future must be written by the people, not Wall Street and Silicon Valley.
4
24
1
128
2,089
No data center in Nevada should be built without a commitment to purchase Nevada-made batteries. There are plenty of battery manufacturers right here in our state, including in my own district, that can meet the energy storage demands of these projects.
1
1
16
749
Serious lawyers - and not just environmental advocates - people like Judge David Tatel and now Steve Vladeck - are sounding the alarm about BAAJA. If you won’t listen to us maybe listen to them. It’s a bad bill with serious long term consequences. open.substack.com/pub/stevev…
7
181
11
319
3,797
Patrick Donnelly retweeted
If BAAJA passes Heinrich Whitehouse and the abundance think tanks will get to own every polluting project that President Trump rams through over the next two years …
17
37
3
145
4,087
I was really making more of a technical point - it's hard to see how Section 106 of NHPA is fully functional if it is being implemented on NEPA documents that are deficient.
The difference is that tribal sovereignty has a normative justification as a veto point that’s distinct from other cases that are just about empowering random NGO litigation teams.
2
19
923
Patrick Donnelly retweeted
The rich psychos profiting off data centers and toxic waste dumps should not get to poison our water whenever they feel like it, actually. Thanks ✌️
The BAAJA environmental protection law rollbacks apply to literally everything. Not just energy but every conceivable action that the feds permit - data centers, toxic waste dumps, biological warfare facilities, medical waste incinerators, you name it. If the feds have a role, this bill handcuffs them. Seems bad if you breathe air or drink water.
25
77
1
317
9,123
The BAAJA environmental protection law rollbacks apply to literally everything. Not just energy but every conceivable action that the feds permit - data centers, toxic waste dumps, biological warfare facilities, medical waste incinerators, you name it. If the feds have a role, this bill handcuffs them. Seems bad if you breathe air or drink water.
37
377
34
845
48,380
Patrick Donnelly retweeted
Congress Shouldn't Weaken Endangered Species Act for Faster Permitting. For >50 years, the ESA has been a bipartisan commitment to preventing extinction. Senators should not trade that for new bureaucratic hurdles & fewer protections for threatened wildlife. us.list-manage.com/F90PwQkrL…
3
89
5
174
1,866
I think it's worth remembering what America looked like before NEPA and the Clean Water Act. 🧵
3
107
5
322
4,785
3-4%? Tell me again about the affordability argument?
5
7
43
1,333
While simultaneously stripping away the enforcement mechanisms for the very laws that might be guardrails on the environmental consequences of data center build out.
4
47
1
120
1,522