richard n beaumont retweeted
I'm going to close the "ecological transition" debate once and for all.
Next time someone lectures you about degrowth and "saving the planet", here's the full genealogy. Bookmark this.
It starts with the Frankfurt School. Their problem: the Western working class never revolted, because capitalism kept making it richer. So Marcuse and co. changed the target. The enemy was no longer poverty. It was abundance itself. Consumer society. Growth.
Add Gramsci's playbook on top: don't seize the factories, seize the culture. Win the schools, the universities, the media, and politics will follow.
In 1972, the Club of Rome publishes The Limits to Growth. An MIT computer model telling the world that growth will hit a wall, resources will run out, collapse will follow. Fun detail: the Club was founded by an industrialist and a technocrat, and the study was funded by the Volkswagen Foundation. That's the trick. The anti-growth idea leaves the radical campus and puts on a lab coat and a suit.
Same year, the Marxist philosopher André Gorz picks it up and gives it a name: "décroissance". Degrowth. The loop is closed: a Marxist critique of abundance, wrapped in a scientific-looking doom model.
Fifty years later, the doom calendar keeps slipping. Extreme poverty has collapsed. Food per capita is up. France, the UK and the US all emit less CO2 than in 2005 with a bigger GDP.
So the narrative needed a new face. Enter Greta Thunberg. Not a scientist. Not an engineer. A teenager on a sailboat telling adults "how dare you". You can't debate a crying child. That's the whole point.
And here's the core sleight of hand: they welded growth and capitalism to the destruction of the planet. As if the solution was to produce less, consume less, build less, live less.
It's exactly backwards.
What decarbonized French electricity? Nuclear. A massive engineering project, not a sobriety campaign. What made solar ~90% cheaper in a decade? Markets, scale and innovation. Poor countries burn their forests. Rich countries replant them. Wealth is what pays for a clean environment.
Today it's dressed up in Davos language. "Great Reset". "You'll own nothing and be happy". Eat bugs. Fly less, drive less, have fewer kids. Rationing sold as virtue, preached by people who fly private to tell you about it.
And it trickles down into French politics. Even the "center" now calls water "the common good of humanity", and the answer to drought is... a new ministry. Always the same reflex: the world is finite, so the State must manage scarcity.
Our answer is the opposite. Scarcity is not a law of nature, it's an engineering problem. Abundant energy. Nuclear. Desalination. Space.
Degrowth isn't ecology. It's a death drive with a green coat of paint.
There is NO limit to growth. 🚀
richard n beaumont retweeted
“But what about the deaths caused by capitalism?”
When discussing economic systems, I often highlight how Marxist socialism devastated Africa and other regions of the world, leading to the deaths of millions of people. Inevitably, someone responds: “But what about the deaths caused by capitalism?”
This response reveals a fundamental misunderstanding that needs addressing. It blames capitalism not just for greed, but for all of humanity’s darker instincts, as if free markets somehow invented human flaws.
Let’s get something straight: greed, exploitation, and cruelty have existed throughout human history, long before anyone conceived of property rights or free enterprise.
1/ Greed Predates Capitalism
Long before Adam Smith put pen to paper, humans had already committed unspeakable acts of greed, conquest, and exploitation:
- Genghis Khan ran a brutal empire that expanded through violence and rape. According to genetic studies, around 8% of men in a large region of Asia carry DNA linked to him.
- The Atlantic Slave Trade was powered by kings, empires, tribal chiefs, and European monarchies, most of whom operated under imperial and monarchical structures.
- In pre-revolutionary France, the monarchy, nobility, and upper clergy lived in great privilege and luxury, while the vast majority of peasants (about 80% of the population) endured poverty, heavy taxation, and frequent hunger.
There have always been selfish, greedy, and rapacious people, and there always will be, as long as humans exist. Every economic and political system has had greedy people in it. The difference is whether that system limits their power or lets it run wild.
2/ The Enemies Invented “Capitalism”
The word “capitalism” was coined by socialist critics in the 19th century, including Louis Blanc, Pierre-Joseph Proudhon and Karl Marx.
They used it to criticize the system they believed would inevitably collapse. Since they coined the term, it means whatever socialists want it to mean. That’s why the socialism vs. capitalism debate is often a Trojan horse to avoid admitting that free markets actually work.
Adam Smith (who is often called the “father of capitalism”) never actually used the word. Instead, he described natural liberty, where:
“Every man, as long as he does not violate the laws of justice, is left perfectly free to pursue his own interest his own way.”
(The Wealth of Nations)
John Locke, whose ideas heavily influenced America’s founding documents, focused on natural rights to “life, liberty, and property” in his Second Treatise of Government (1689). He argued these rights existed prior to government, which was instituted specifically to protect them.
When the American Founders created the US Constitution, they didn’t use the word capitalism either. The Bill of Rights protects individual freedoms like freedom of speech, religion, assembly, property, and due process, all of which protect individuals from both tyrants and mobs.
In other words, the core principles we now associate with “capitalism” were never about enriching the few. They were about protecting the many from power, whether it came from kings, mobs, or bureaucrats.
3/ Voluntary Socialism
Here’s the thing: if a group of people want to live communally, they should absolutely have that freedom. Such voluntary arrangements don’t require state coercion or enforcement.
For instance:
- The Amish live simply and share resources, but joining is voluntary, and people are free to leave if they choose.
- Kibbutzim are intentional communities in Israel, traditionally based on agriculture and collective ownership. Membership is voluntary, and individuals are free to leave at any time.
- Monasteries and religious orders have lived communally for centuries and continue to operate around the world, with monks and nuns sharing resources, labor, and prayer.
This is voluntary socialism, and no free-market advocate has a problem with it.
Marxist socialism is something else entirely. It calls for revolution, the abolition of private property, and stateless dictatorships with no respect for individual rights. It caused 65–94 million deaths, with some estimates exceeding 100 million.
It’s worth noting that capitalism even gives people the freedom to experiment with Marxist ideals.
In a free market, you’re allowed to create worker-owned businesses based on Marx’s labor theory of value if you want to. Cooperatives, mutual aid societies, and communal living models can and do exist under capitalism.
Every system has greedy people, but only free market capitalism, rooted in individual rights and the rule of law, limits their power through competition, transparency, and choice.
richard n beaumont retweeted
To every American, and to everyone watching France burn from abroad:
Do not blame the French people for this.
We never asked for it. We never voted for it. And the one time we were clearly asked, we said no.
Here are the numbers your media won't show you.
70% of the French say there are too many immigrants in France today.
79% want a tougher immigration policy.
77% disapprove of the government's record on immigration.
83% want foreign criminals and long-term unemployed foreigners sent home.
And no, it's not just the old. 69% of French 18 to 24 year olds support suspending legal immigration for three years.
This is not a fringe. This is the French people.
In 2005, we were asked if we wanted the European Constitution. 55% voted no. Three years later, our politicians passed the same text under another name, through parliament, without ever asking us again.
That is modern France in one sentence. The people say no. The elites do it anyway.
So who is responsible? The politicians who lied to us. A class of leaders formed in the same schools, the same forums, the same networks, loyal to each other before they are loyal to their nations.
In 2017, at Harvard, Klaus Schwab, founder of the World Economic Forum, bragged about his Young Global Leaders program in four words: "We penetrate the cabinets." He added that it was true in France. Emmanuel Macron was one of his Young Global Leaders.
It's the same project in Brussels with Ursula von der Leyen and in Paris with Macron. Borders treated as an obstacle. Nations treated as relics. The people treated as a problem to be managed.
What you are watching in France is not the French people failing. It is the end of the globalist project, an abject, quasi-communist dream of a world run by unelected planners. It is collapsing everywhere in Europe at once, and the West has to cut this cancer out before it takes the rest of the body with it.
The peoples of Europe don't want this. They never did.
So when you see our town halls burning, don't say "the French chose this."
The French never chose this.
They were forced into it.
If you're French and you agree, repost this so the world hears it from us.
If you're American, look at us carefully. Then choose differently on November 3rd.
richard n beaumont retweeted
96% of Jews in Poland were murdered by the Nazis. That is genocide.
3% of Gaza’s population, mostly male combatants, died in the war they started. That is not genocide.
Without lies, Palestine dies.
Pass it on.
richard n beaumont retweeted
They don't want to cancel Ed Sheeran.
They want to ensure that no artist feels safe expressing unapproved opinions on any topic.
It's a narrative capture. Textbook Marxism.
richard n beaumont retweeted
Gillian Anderson made a video for War Child about children in Sudan. Look at what her comments turned into. Hundreds of people, with pitchforks. Calling her a “zio” “heartless” and worse, for asking people to feed kids.
I’m not saying don’t talk about Gaza. Talk about Gaza. And it’s not a competition over whose suffering is worse. But Sudan is far worse, even if you believe Hamas, by every number there is.
150,000 to 400,000 dead. Thirteen million people out of their homes, five million of them children. 825,000 kids under five who will die this year without treatment. Famine officially declared. No ceasefire. The UN appeal is sixteen percent funded. And almost nobody is talking about it, and when someone finally does, this is what she gets. Sure, you can justify it to yourself with excuses like “I care about Gaza because America supports Israel” but if that’s your reason for caring, it’s a sad one.
If you have to check where the starving children are from before you decide whether to care and post it about, it stopped being about children a long time ago. It’s about you.
richard n beaumont retweeted
Replying to @Emeraldfifi @_ayandamay
Source: trust me bro
I think we know who the “butchers” are, grifter.
richard n beaumont retweeted
Anti-Israel Professor Ilan Pappé’s “idea for peace” at the Oxford Union: send me and my family “back” to Iraq. And the students cheered.
A professor who built an entire career on the words “ethnic cleansing” stood up and proposed one. For me and my family.
Here is what he doesn’t want you to think about:
Millions of Israeli Jews are Mizrahi, roughly half of Israel’s Jewish population, the children and grandchildren of Jews from the Middle East and North Africa. Iraq, Yemen, Morocco, Tunisia, Libya, Syria, Egypt, Algeria, Iran. We didn’t come from Europe. Over 850,000 of us were expelled or driven out of the Arab world, stripped of citizenship, homes and everything we owned.
So “cleansing” Israel of Mizrahi Jews isn’t a peace plan. It’s a selection process. Who goes? The grandson of Iraqi Jews, or the grandson of Polish ones? And what about the millions of us who are both? And the other half? Send them “back” to Warsaw, Vilnius, Berlin? To communities that were wiped out down to the last child? My family is from Iraq and Tunisia. Which half of me goes where? Most of us cannot divide ourselves in half.
And “back” to what? Iraq stripped its Jews of citizenship and seized their property. It hanged Jews in a public square in Baghdad in 1969. In 2022 its parliament made contact with Israelis a crime punishable by death. There are no Jews left in Iraq. That is the “welcome” Pappé is so sure of. There is no “back” for any of us. That’s why Israel exists.
The Farhud, the pogrom that ended my grandmother’s childhood in Baghdad, was in 1941. Seven years before Israel existed. Iraq did not expel its Jews because of anything Israel did.
Pappé knows all of this. He just leaves it out.
Where is your family from? Tell me in the comments: Baghdad, Tunis, Sana’a, Casablanca, Aleppo, Tehran, Warsaw, Vienna, Budapest, Prague, Vilnius, Kyiv, Bucharest. I want them to see how many of us there are.
Share this with anyone who still thinks Israelis are “colonizers.”
#JewishRefugees #OxfordUnion #IlanPappe #Israel #palestine
richard n beaumont retweeted
Jews came from Judea. Arabs came from Arabia.
Jews reclaimed a sliver smaller than New Jersey.
Arabs conquered 11+ million sq miles of other peoples’ land—20% of Earth’s landmass.
Can someone please remind me again who the colonizers are?
richard n beaumont retweeted
La marca de lujo "Prada" y el músico palestino Saint Levant,
(Embajador de la marca) publicita sus productos, luciendo un colgante con un falso mapa de Palestina (del río al mar).
Si @Prada promueve la EXTINCIÓN de Israel, promovamos no consumir Prada.
ME AYUDAS COMPARTIENDO ?
richard n beaumont retweeted
Israel has made peace with Egypt, Jordan, the UAE, Bahrain, and Morocco.
What a "miraculous coincidence" that none of them is among the seven fronts Israel is fighting. So don't give me that "Israel doesn't want to make peace" crap.
- @KosherChutzpah
richard n beaumont retweeted
Since “Palestinians” were always considered just Arabs up until the Soviets gave them their own “Palestinian” identity in the 1960s, being controlled by other Arab nations was never a problem for the people of those areas.
Despite Israel giving them more self-determination options than the Arabized nations of Egypt and Jordan, the Palestinians used their self-determination opportunities to determine that they hated Jews.
Higher education did not help.
Kind of ironic.
richard n beaumont retweeted
Genuinely, socialism is the best sounding system.
It makes perfect sense for a society to work together to elevate the living standards of everyone together.
It makes sense that if someone builds something of enormous value, we accept that it was inevitable that it would have been created at some point and that it was society as a whole that went into the discovery.
It seems fair that we would all accept that people have vastly different abilities that yield very different commercial value. How unfair that the person who is naturally good at negotiating a roll-up acquisition strategy is wildly more rewarded than the nurse who returns someone to health or who allows someone to die with dignity.
Honestly, I see it. I understand it.
The issue is that we are primates running on ancient software. We don’t do stuff for the collective good, we do stuff for our kids.
The person who strives for an A on the exam doesn’t study if the grades are equalised. The entrepreneur doesn’t start the company when half the rewards are redistributed to those who didn’t - even though they couldn’t.
We’re happy sharing to an extent but we’re not content to put it all in the pot. We’re happy to help those who clearly cannot survive on their own but we’re not happy supporting those who don’t want to work or who struggle to get motivated or focused.
Socialism is the smartest system but it doesn’t actually work and has never worked. Really smart people like socialism because they can see how much better society could be … if only it worked.
Even John Lennon kept the royalties to Imagine. His heirs will never need to work again from that one song alone. If he truly believed what he was saying, he would declare that it belongs to “all the people living for today”.
Capitalists accept human nature. We know there is a better way but we know it’s out of reach. We understand that if you can harness self interest in a pro-social way you will lift living standards enormously. The restaurant owner will feed the village not because it’s good for society but because it’s good for his kids… either way the village is fed. John Lennon will write uplifting songs … but only if he owns the rights.
The most important part about capitalism isn’t that it’s better - it’s not. It’s that it actually works in the real world.
richard n beaumont retweeted
Today, on my final day as Director of National Intelligence, I’m releasing never-before-seen communications and documents exposing how Dr. Fauci provided millions in US taxpayer dollars to fund dangerous gain-of-function research at the Wuhan lab, worked with politicized elements within the Intelligence Community to suppress the truth about his actions and hide the virus’ lab-leak origins, and lied to Congress while under oath in 2024. It’s time you know the truth.
odni.gov/index.php/newsroom/…
When it is discovered that Trump is enriching himself and family and betraying the USA, the West, Israel and the Iranian people, I hope he is convicted of Treason and goes to the gallows. Him and his crook family.
1
46
How does Qatar, with a GDP of under $250 billion, invest “$19.2 Trillion” in the USA as Trump claims. He has lost his mind.
38






















