Rod Everson retweeted
Teacher-led, explicit instruction of content-rich, cohesive curriculum is the most effective model for educating students. A true education also involves the formation of the whole person. This is why I am such a strong a proponent of classical education.
While the modern education establishment bounces around from one fad to another (often doing everything except what works) classical schools persist in the tried and true method of education.
The old saying “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” comes to mind.
Rod Everson retweeted
Replying to @roblevine82 @ehanford
The facts are, considering the impact COVID had on education after 2019, Mississippi does start to stand out for relative Grade 8 NAEP Reading performance.
You don't get it, but other readers deserve the whole story.
Rod Everson retweeted
Giving novices problems they lack the knowledge to solve makes little sense. Ausubel said this in 1968 and it still holds true.
"If I have to reduce all educational psychology to just one principle, I would say this: the most important single factor influencing learning is what the learner already knows. Ascertain this and teach [the learner] accordingly."
-David Ausubel
Rod Everson retweeted
One thing substitute teaching does is give me a measure of the state of education in a community. In one school a 13 year old girl with zero developmental delays is allowed to be unable to write her own name. In another school across town 7 year olds immersed in a language they never hear at home are chatting over their teacher in fluent French while learning pre algebra. Both sets of children are white and of the same or close to same economic class. The class divide will be among these children. It won't matter what race, skin color or background they come from. It will matter who is literate & numerate and who is not.
Rod Everson retweeted
"We're flipping them like pancakes!" Amy's pull-out kids now exit intervention in as little as 8 weeks.
Why do kids sit in intervention for months? We wait for mastery. Move on at about 70%. They'll keep practicing the old pattern inside the new one.
I finally finished Season 1 of Sold a Story, the podcast that helped push American schools to rethink how they teach reading. And I’m still stuck on this: how did “guess the word” become a teaching strategy?
(It’s called cueing. When children get stuck, they’re encouraged to look at the picture, think about what would make sense in the sentence, and use clues like the first letter. Basically, make an educated guess.)
As someone who learned English as a second language, I find this baffling. My first reaction was: didn’t we all learn phonics?
Actually, what I remember learning was 国际音标 aka the International Phonetic Alphabet, or IPA. Those funny-looking symbols in dictionaries that tell you how a word is pronounced and which syllable to stress.
But explicitly learning how words sounded was such a basic part of learning English for me. I’m still trying to wrap my head around how “look at the picture and guess” became accepted practice, while teaching children the relationship between letters and sounds became controversial. I literally did not think it's possible that people could be illiterate in English. It's so much easier than Chinese
Could have just asked the immigrants how we all learned to read. Definitely not cueing
Rod Everson retweeted
Where will you send your $1700?
If you make >$40K, come January you have a choice to make.
You can send $1700 of your federal taxes to:
a) the IRS as you normally do, or
a) an org that pays tuition to private schools or
b) an org that pays for supports for public school kids
Rod Everson retweeted
THE BILLION-DOLLAR GUESSING GAME: How Education "Gurus" Hijacked Literacy and Broke a Generation of Readers
For more than three decades, a catastrophic medical and educational fraud was quietly perpetrated inside public elementary schools across North America. Under the noses of unsuspecting parents, a cabal of university education theorists and multi-million-dollar corporate publishers systematically ripped down the foundational mechanic of human literacy—phonics—and replaced it with a method that can only be described as absolute, unadulterated bullshit.
They stopped teaching children how to look at letters and sound out words. Instead, they literally trained children to look at pictures, guess blindly, and memorize entire shapes of words like Chinese ideograms.
The result? A generation of children functionally crippled in their ability to decode the written English language. The fraud was so deeply entrenched, and the institutional pride so fiercely protected, that it has taken an unprecedented wave of furious parents, cognitive neuroscientists, and emergency state laws to literally make the education establishment’s preferred teaching method illegal.
The Architecture of the Fraud: "Balanced Literacy"
The disaster began with a romantic, unscientific theory born in university education departments called "Whole Language," which later rebranded itself under the reassuring, corporate name "Balanced Literacy."[1, 2]
The architects of this system—pioneered by figures like Ken Goodman and monetized into a multi-billion-dollar empire by celebrity education authors like Lucy Calkins—promoted a beautiful lie: Reading is as natural as talking. They argued that if you just surround a child with beautiful books and instill a "love of reading," the brain will naturally figure out how to decode text by osmosis.
Phonics—the systematic process of teaching a child that the letter "B" makes the /b/ sound and blending those sounds together—was demonized. Cultish teachers' colleges attacked phonics as an outdated, right-wing, mechanical drill that treated children like robots and sucked the joy out of literature.
In its place, they installed the "Three-Cueing System." Teachers were explicitly instructed to cover up words and tell struggling six-year-olds to perform a series of mental gymnastics instead of looking at the letters:
1Look at the picture and guess what word fits.
2Look at the first letter and guess a word that starts with that sound.
3Skip the word entirely and guess based on the context of the sentence.
Cognitive scientists would later point out the horror of this design: Three-Cueing didn’t teach kids how to read; it literally taught them the exact coping mechanisms of illiterate adults.
Rod Everson retweeted
Replying to @MrZachG
I met a lady about 20 years ago, she was in her 90's then. She taught in a one room schoolhouse in Texas, all her classes were 40 to 50 students, mixed ages.
She said they all behaved, and she taught phonics, and they all learned to read!!
She didn't understand why any of this would be in question.
Interesting lady, her 4 brothers all fought in WWII, only 2 of the 4 survived.
She never married, lived with her dad, then lived on her own after he died, then in a nursing home.
Rod Everson retweeted
Watch or read the interview with Nora, Holly Korbey, and me about linguistic phonics here:
hollykorbey.substack.com/p/i…
Rod Everson retweeted
Meet Tara Hess, a fellow S2P educator. Tara is a wonderful educator who has learned how 2 accelerate growth & continues to work on refining her teaching skills year after year. Read her story in the thread⬇️
@D99Cicero @tara_deann @ReadSimplified @SoRclassroom
Rod Everson retweeted
I’m 55-years-young today, and my birthday wish is wild: I want every single American who is concerned about kids’ plummeting reading scores to listen to the TikTok and share this post like it’s the last slice of cake at my party! 🥳
Let’s 'yeet' the reading crisis out of U.S. schools, together! 🇺🇸
Rod Everson retweeted
The patients who don't recover from concussion aren't the ones with the worst injuries. They're the ones who were never treated for the right thing.
Cervicogenic dizziness.
Convergence insufficiency.
Vestibular-visual mismatch.
These are not vague sequelae of a brain injury. They are specific, diagnosable, treatable conditions that persist in the background of post-concussive syndrome because no one looked for them.
Convergence insufficiency — the inability to sustain convergent eye position at near distance — is present in a documented proportion of concussed patients and is a direct cause of the reading difficulty and screen intolerance they report. It responds to vision therapy. It does not respond to rest.
The patients still symptomatic at three months aren't failing to recover. They're recovering from an injury that was never fully diagnosed.
The brain injury may have resolved. The cervical spine, the vestibular system, and the visual system are still waiting for treatment.
Rod Everson retweeted
The largest study ever done on school phone bans just looked at more than 40,000 schools, and the result is more honest than either side wanted. Locking phones away clearly improved students' wellbeing and cut classroom distraction. It did almost nothing to test scores.
Both camps will misread this. Phone-ban champions promised sharper grades and will be disappointed. Sceptics will say it did not even raise scores, so why bother. Both are asking the wrong question, because they have quietly decided that the only thing that matters about a child is a number on a standardised test.
Look at what the study actually found. The phones were not mainly hurting test performance. They were hurting something harder to measure and far more important: how young people feel, how present they are, whether they can sit in a room and be bored, and social, and awake to the world in front of them. Wellbeing is not a soft consolation prize next to grades. For a developing human, it may be the whole game.
That is the trap of measuring only what is easy to measure. We track test scores because they are convenient, then slowly convince ourselves that what we can count is all that counts. A childhood is not an exam. The things a phone quietly steals from a kid, attention, patience, real friendship, the ability to be unstimulated for five minutes, never show up on the report card, which is exactly why we keep trading them away.
Rod Everson retweeted
It's...literally not hard. You don't give them screens, read to them, play audio books while they play, & teach them to read. My 11yo reads everything from classics to graphic novels, I can't keep enough books around cause he reads 2-3 per day. And you have to read too
Rod Everson retweeted
My 5th grade class will read about 10 novels as a class this year. We will also read many texts in science and social studies (Core Knowledge) which aren't short passages. This is how my Ss did on the 5th grade ELA compared to every district in my county. I despise test prep.
Rod Everson retweeted
My prediction: the UCSD report is going to go down as a watershed moment in public opinion about K-12 education.
This story is reverberating, and it seems to portend a shift.
I made a similar call seven years ago.
When @ehanford’s Hard Words came out in 2018, I sensed something was shifting. The outsize response to that piece was becoming part of the story.
I wrote a series of articles on the “Literacy Tsunami,” chronicling the teacher response, downstream media, and growing advocacy. In the years that followed, we would come to call the response to her work “the Hanford Effect.”
The Hanford effect was never simply about the journalism–although Hanford’s exceptional storytelling certainly helped!
Rather, the Hanford effect was initially measured in the social media response to her work. Later, it was measured in the energized dyslexia parent groups, the growing teacher Facebook groups, the rise of new influencers like the Reading League, the emergence of a handful of new podcasts, a series of curriculum shifts, and a national wave of policy spanning every state between 2019 and 2024 (and propelled by the energy of organized dyslexia parents).
Today, I sense a similar breakthrough, as a new generation of journalists takes on issues with academics in US schools. I’ll call it the Piper/Kahloon/Rice/Horowitch/Thompson/Yglesias effect.
I’m predicting the UCSD. story will be its infection point. The UCSD story is the one that won’t leave social media.
This current wave is more complex, because phonics instruction was always a simpler story than “core academics in American schools.”
Still, it’s a shift worth noting.
Rod Everson retweeted
Public education dollars are moving to the private sector. There should be a Cambrian explosion in the edtech ecosystem. Get on board!
Replying to @mbateman
Another number not on the radar yet: $170 billion per year starting in 2027.
That's the dollar amount generated if 100 million taxpayers owing more than $1700 in federal income tax designate that amount to a Scholarship Granting Organization (SGO), a new opportunity created in the Big Beautiful Bill this year.
The report to Congress estimated it would re-direct about $26 billion over ten years.
But why wouldn't nearly every taxpayer rather decide which educational SGO gets his tax dollars, rather than just send it in to the government, unallocated as usual?
Expect the advertising by SGO's to rival that of Medicare supplemental plans next fall. Also, expect a serious revision of that $26 billion estimate.





























