Nova retweeted
Got confirmation from the editor: they’re running the story.
One of the reporters became particularly interested in the case. He’d been through a toxic PhD adviser himself and had already heard a lot of concerns about Sabine Kastner before we spoke.
Princeton’s internal investigation concluded that I was removed from the program because I “did not find an advisor.”
But I have a recording of the meeting where department leadership, Yael Niv and Casey Lew-Williams, told me why I was removed.
I never gave that recording to Princeton’s investigations unit. They didn’t even know it existed. Because I never had confidence that the university was handling the case fairly.
If they knew the meeting was recorded, I don’t think they would have given investigators an account that the recording contradicts. Because what was actually said in that room tells a very different story about why I was removed from the program.
So I gave the recording to journalists instead.
Princeton says I was removed because I “did not find an advisor.” Now the department can explain how that conclusion fits with what its own leadership actually said in the room.
#ResearchIntegrity #AcademicFreedom #Whistleblower #Retaliation #HigherEducation #PhD #GraduateSchool #AcademicIntegrity #ResearchEthics #Princeton #InvestigativeJournalism #Accountability
Nova retweeted
🚨美国版“耿同学”出现了?
普林斯顿中国留学生实名举报导师学术造假!
近日,普林斯顿大学心理学、神经科学系教授 Sabine Kastner被前组员在小红书上密集曝光:多篇顶刊(包括 Science、Nature Neuroscience)核心结果无法复现,要求学生、博后 cherry-pick 数据、删除不符合预期的结果,对不听话和举报的人直接开除。
实验室国际学生(尤其中国学生)占比极高,所以选择先在中文平台公开。
举报人(账号None of this matters)称:
去年10月因拒绝删除不符预期数据,被研究生主任 YN 和系主任 CLW 约谈。
系主任原话(英文原句+翻译):
“You questioned her (SK’s) integrity. We are a community. You attack one of us, you attack all of us.”
(举报就是质疑导师的人格,我们这些教授是一家人,你攻击一个人,就是攻击我们所有人。)
“There is free speech, and then there are consequences of free speech.”
(你有言论自由,但你要付出相应的代价。)
CLW 还说:“She (SK) demands loyalty. And I understand that.”
(SK 要求组员对她忠诚。我理解她。)
举报人随后向学校正式上报报复吹哨人,学校启动调查并保护了举报人,才得以留到现在。后续会陆续公开与 YN、CLW 以及普林斯顿调查组的邮件,以及更多无法复现的论文(已点名 Konen & Kastner 2008 Nature Neuroscience,多名前博后独立复现失败,最早可追溯到近20年前)。
目前已上报学校与NIH Office of Research Integrity。更多 raw data、code 和前组员证言正在整理中。
学术共同体如果把质疑数据直接等同于攻击人格,把忠诚置于可复现性之上,那这个系统本身就出了问题,即使是普林斯顿。
关注后续,证据说话。
Nova retweeted
Alleged research misconduct by Sabine Kastner, and silencing whistleblowers by the psychology department at Princeton Univeristy.
Multiple former members of the Kastner Lab at Princeton University, including former postdocs and graduate students, have formally reported research misconduct by Professor Sabine Kastner, including alleged data falsification spanning over 20 years.
They describe a culture where people feared speaking up. Some remained anonymous because they feared retaliation.
My own experience: after I raised concerns, I was removed from Kastner lab. I was explicitly told by the psychology department leadership that this happened because I raised concerns anonymously: they told me “you questioned her integrity. PNI is a community. You attack one of us, you attack all of us.”
Afterward, I could not secure a new adviser and my PhD enrollment was terminated through the “no active adviser” rule.
Many affected trainees were international students. Losing an adviser means losing visa status, and international relocation, creating enormous pressure not to report concerns. This is exactly why Kastner lab recruits a disproportionately high number of international trainees. And why the lab website has most former members erased.
The research involved is supported by active NIH grants of over $20m. Involved publications include papers in Science, Nature Neuroscience, and Neuron.
The departmental leadership has been complicit, by helping remove students who raised concerns instead of protecting them.
Over the coming weeks, I will post documents, timelines, and evidence so people can examine the facts themselves.
#ResearchIntegrity #Whistleblower #Science #NIH #HigherEducation #GraduateSchool #PhD #Retaliation #OpenScience #ResearchEthics #AcademicFreedom @ivanoransky @NIH @HHSGov










