Oblivious (@PrimitiveBanker) profile picture
Joined March 2020
Ananth Narayan has a sharp piece in Business Standard today on why Indian banking needs its own 1991 moment. His argument is not that government should sell its banks. It is that government should stop running them like a department. The Narasimham committees of 1991 and 1998 and the P J Nayak committee of 2014 all said the same thing in different words: professional boards, freedom from day to day interference, and RBI regulation that treats public and private banks alike. Thirty five years later most of it is still on paper. He also reminds us why these banks matter. An RBI study by its own economists in 2022 found that private banks are more profit-efficent, but public sector banks did better on financial inclusion and kept lending even in bad times. Public sector banks still hold over 80% of rural deposits and around 70% in semi-urban India. The farmer, the small trader and the pensioner in a district town are banking with them, not with the glass towers we see in advertisements. Now look at IDBI Bank. If the problem was governance, the remedy was a professional board and real autonomy. Instead 60.72% of a profitable bank is going to one private buyer at ₹81 a share, with full management control. Some will say Narasimham-II itself proposed bringing government ownership down to 33%, and government and LIC are keeping 34%. But that proposal kept the state as the largest owner while freeing the board. It never suggested handing control of a public bank to a single promoter. The article's own example makes this clear, Singapore's Temasek owns 28% of DBS and still no single private owner runs that bank. The country spent heavily to clean up these banks. Between FY10 and FY25 public sector banks, IDBI included, wrote off about ₹13.6 lakh crore of loans, and between FY13 and FY22 government put in ₹3.75 lakh crore of capital. Taxpayers paid for the cure. Selling the patient the moment it recovers, instead of giving it the autonomy every committee recomended, is a curious way to celebrate that recovery. Reform the governance, keep 51%, and let IDBI compete on a level playing field. That would be a 1991 moment worth having. Source: Ananth Narayan, "Banking needs its 1991 moment", Business Standard, 17 Nov 2026 @ananthng
4
73
2
76
2,623
Sensational Corruption - IDBI FairFax Deal Officials First Opened the Envelope, Checked the Bid Price and then Set new min Price, as Bid price was lower than min benchmark as per report🤯 👇 businessworld.in/article/sen…
23
530
7
908
20,985
Indians not reminding their bosses that it's 5 PM or the weekend isn't a sign of dedication, Goyal ji. It's a sign of a system where people are so replaceable that they cannot afford to say NO. When workers are afraid to demand their evenings, weekends, and basic dignity, that's not a work ethic. "THAT'S EXPLOITATION." And when a Commerce Minister proudly markets that helplessness to foreign investors as India's competitive advantage, the problem isn't the Indian worker. It's the leadership that sees human exhaustion as an economic asset. A country's strength lies in how well it treats its workers, not in how much exploitation they can silently endure. Stop glorifying a compulsion that you would never want your own family to live under.
“Indians want to work hard. Nobody in India will tell you it’s five o’clock. And certainly no Indian will ever remind you it’s the weekend,” jokes Commerce Minister Goyal with Dutch business leaders
48
307
3
1,154
19,352
#StandWithIDBI is trending at No. 8 in India within minutes of starting. 🙏 This is not about one bank. It is about jobs, reservation, Jan Dhan accounts and a public institution built over 60 years. Keep the promise. Keep 51%. @IdbiFor @idesibanda
10
110
5
69
1,129
Oblivious retweeted
If the government genuinely wants to curb liquidity in Indian equity markets, here are some policy recommendations: 1. Raise LTCG tax retrospectively to 20.47% so that FII are not able to exit longterm holdings. Apt lesson for the goras. 2. Re-KYC everytime a broker login is done. Plus an NOC from five ministries, renewed monthly, mandatory for selling. 3. Exit Transaction Tax (ETT) on every sell order. Plus 56% Liquidity Cess on that ETT. Selling of stocks leads to capital outflows & must be discouraged. 4. All price bands should be capped to 5% maximum. After all why does a stock need to move 10, 20% in a day. 5. Launch a National Liquidity Eradication Mission (NLEM) under a Bharatiya Nirdhan Trader committee with a ₹78,000 crore budget to investigate why liquidity is so abundant. Na rahegi liquidity, na hogi underperformance. 💪
Excess liquidity in India’s equity market has contributed to underperformance and may continue to do so, according to Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman. “Because of the ease of liquidity, ease of availability, people are even exiting easily” from equities, Sitharaman told CNBC in an exclusive interview on the sidelines of the IMF-World Bank meetings in Bangkok on Friday. However, the fundamentals of the Indian economy are “fine,” she said.
145
168
29
1,397
93,465
Rajya Sabha MP ne sansadiya jaanch maangi hai. Itne bade sauda ki sansad mein charcha kyun nahi? Bahas se dar kaisa? 🎤 #IDBINotForSale #SaveIDBI
5
129
5
122
2,848
Read Prof. Arvind Panagariya's piece in ET today, "Pivot to Privatisation 2.0". With all respect to the Chairman of the 16th Finance Commission, I did not need a single outside fact to answer it. His own article does the job! He says there is "enormous wisdom in transferring the bank to private hands now, when its healthy books enable it to attract buyers". Healthy books made by whom? By his own figures, gross NPA fell from 21.25% to 2.32% and CRAR rose from 10.7% to 26.65% while LIC and the Government owned the bank. So the "healthy books" are the proof that public ownership worked, not a reason to end it. He says it is best to close or sell PSBs "that regularly drain government finances". His own article says IDBI made a record profit of ₹9,513 crore in 2025-26. By his own test, IDBI does not even qualify for sale! He says repeated support "amounts to throwing good money after bad". His own numbers: GoI put in ₹27,441 crore and LIC ₹26,367 crore. That money did not go waste, it built a bank earning ₹9,513 crore a year. Good money after bad is when the patient dies. Here the patient walked out of the hospital, and we are selling him at the gate. He says GoI and LIC, with 15% and 19%, "stand to share in the benefits almost certain to accrue". If the benefits are almost certain, why sell 60.72% of them? And the sale brings ₹52,879 crore against roughly ₹53,800 crore of public money put in. Where is the fiscal gain? He says worker and wage concerns "lacked empirical support", citing a study of 14 Vajpayee-era privatisations. Not one of them was a bank. And if he is so sure employees will be better off, the government should have no hesitation in giving IDBI staff written statutory protection. The union is asking for exactly that. He compares it with Air India, sold with ₹61,000 crore of debt settled at taxpayers' expense. IDBI carries no such burden. One was bleeding, the other is earning. His subheading says "non-strategic PSBs", yet his own last paragraph lists "banking, insurance and financial services" among the four strategic sectors of the 2021 policy, and his own caveat says "provided national security or strategic concerns are not at stake". So we must ask, who examined that before handing an Indian bank to a foreign group? In 2018 I wrote about "अश्वत्थामा हतः" and how nobody hears "नरो वा कुंजरो वा". Today also, "biggest FDI" is announced loudly, while the turnaround under public ownership is said softly. And in December 2003 Parliament was assured majority ownership would stay. "रघुकुल रीति सदा चलि आई। प्रान जाहुँ बरु बचनु न जाई॥" Keep 51%. @DFS_India @narendramodi @nsitharaman
8
77
1
93
6,298
बैंककर्मिओं के कामकाज की हालत,काम का दबाव टारगेट का "टॉर्चर"अब बहुत जानलेवा हो गया है! सिर्फ चंडीगढ़ में पंजाब एंड सिंध बैंक में पिछले तीन दिन में दो बैंककर्मिओं ने सुसाइड कर लिया है! इनकी कोई बात सुनने वाला नहीं है! लाखों बैंककर्मिओं की काम करने की दशा पर बात कीजिये!
41
580
16
1,352
28,436
One of most capable Chief manager of Punjab and Sind Bank (Airport road Mohali Branch) committed suicide today. One more suicide case in banking industry due to extreme work load @idesibanda
7
90
3
198
22,302
Oblivious retweeted
Democracy grants equal rights to stupid people to express their opinions... That's how stupidity becomes a pandemic in democracies.
I support Modi’s move to privatize IDBI bank. Privatize all PSBs.
5
23
85
2,031
25 failed Private Banks saved by Public Sector Banks since nationalization, then Why IDBI Bank not merged in PSBs, but Sold to foreign hands?
69
714
19
1,744
72,101
Oblivious retweeted
“Bankers have no hard skills” is a wild take about people handling credit appraisal, risk, compliance, forex, treasury, audits and financial operations every freaking day. And “just leave the job” isn’t an argument for bad working conditions. By that logic, labour rights wouldn’t exist anywhere in the world. Software engineers switching jobs is mobility. Bankers demanding better conditions is collective bargaining. Different industries, different leverage. Bro really compared GitHub with a bank ledger and thought he cooked. 😂
Remember, bankers do not have hard skills on which they can get a job in the market (except 5%). That's why they can only rant. Software engineers just leave when they do not like any of the things in the job.
17
93
4
389
17,264
Oblivious retweeted
*Banks are open today despite it being Sunday.* Narayana Murthy:
45
520
19
8,420
217,935
Are they talking about this Joint Note 🚬
🤖 Made with AI
15
1
70
1,610
Replying to @PrimitiveBanker
बहुत कम लोगों को ये जानकारी है कि हरिशंकर परसाई जी ने ये केवल बैंको की मैनेजमेंट के लिए लिखा था 👇👇 "जो पानी छानकर पीते हैं, वो आदमी का खून बिना छाने पी जाते हैं।"
3
5
142
मैं बैंक कर्मचारियों के हफ्ते में 5 डे वर्किंग का पुरजोर समर्थन करता हूं। बल्कि बैंकिंग ही नहीं, भारत की सभी सरकारी और प्राइवेट कंपनियों में 5 डे वर्किंग ही होना चाहिए। इस मामले में सख़्त कानून भी बने तो मैं उसका स्वागत करूंगा। लेकिन हमारे देश में आज भी नारायण मूर्ति अंकल जैसे लोग हैं, जो हफ्ते में 70-70 घंटे काम करवाने के हिमायती हैं, मगर तिजोरी से सही अनुपात में सैलरी नहीं निकलती। ऐसी परिस्थितियों में इंसान काम तो करता है, लेकिन वो एफिशिएंट नहीं होगा और काम के प्रति समर्पण (dedication) भी नहीं होगा। वो सिर्फ़ 9 से 6 की ड्यूटी करेगा, ओनरशिप नहीं लेगा। ऑफिस के माहौल में ये चीज़ें सबसे ज़रूरी हैं और यहीं से सबसे ज्यादा conflict पैदा होता है। दुनिया के सारे विकसित देश वर्क-लाइफ बैलेंस को महत्व देते हैं, जिससे मेंटल हेल्थ अच्छा रहता है और आदमी ज्यादा प्रोडक्टिव बनता है। लेकिन हमारे यहां कम पैसे में ज्यादा काम और देर तक काम करवाने की आदत है। टाइम से आना तो आपका संवैधानिक कर्तव्य जैसा है, मगर टाइम से जाना अपराध है। टाइम पर सैलरी नहीं देना, रोक कर रखना, ब्लैकमेल करना और इसके अलावा भारतीय कंपनियों की एक और खासियत है। वो ज्यादातर 1-30 तारीख की सैलरी महीने के आखिर में या अगले महीने की एक तारीख पर देने की बजाय 7-8 तक या कहीं-कहीं उससे भी लेट देते हैं। ये इसलिए कि स्टाफ छोड़कर जाए तो उसकी सैलरी होल्ड करके उसे ब्लैकमेल किया जाए। देश में लेबर लॉ भी एक मज़ाक है। कंपनियां सरकार के माध्यम से अपने हिसाब से, खुद के फायदे के लिए नीतियां बनवाती हैं। मालिक की मर्ज़ी होगी, "कल से मत आओ", तो "मत आओ"। ये तो हो गई ऑफिस की बात और आम लोगों की आर्थिक सुरक्षा की बात। इसके अलावा आम आदमी की जिंदगी आसान कैसे बने और उसे कौन से फैक्टर सबसे ज्यादा प्रभावित करते हैं, ये बहुत बेसिक चीज़ है, लेकिन इस पर कोई बात ही नहीं होती। इनमें सबसे महत्वपूर्ण हैं - शिक्षा, स्वास्थ्य और सोशल सिक्योरिटी। मिडल क्लास का एक आदमी पूरी जिंदगी इन्हीं में उलझा रहता है। बच्चे के जन्म से लेकर उसे पढ़ाने-लिखाने तक का खर्चा क्या है, वो आप सब जानते हैं, जो बढ़ता ही जा रहा है - क्या गांव और क्या शहर? स्वास्थ्य का भी वही हाल है। मेडिकल चीज़ों और इलाज़ पर बेइंतहा खर्चा है। सरल शब्दों में, ₹1.5 करोड़ में डॉक्टर बनेंगे तो पैसा तो मरीजों से ही वसूला जाएगा। कोई गंभीर बीमारी हो गई तो आप बर्बाद हैं। शिक्षा और स्वास्थ्य सरकार अपने नियंत्रण में उत्कृष्ट तरीके से चलाए तो देश की आधी से ज्यादा समस्या ख़त्म हो जाएगी। लेकिन सरकार क्या कर रही है? स्कूल-कॉलेज बंद हो रहे हैं। जो हैं, उनकी गुणवत्ता भी ख़त्म की जा रही है। इनकी कीमत पर एक पूरी महंगी प्राइवेट लॉबी पनपने दी जा रही है। मध्यम वर्ग बेहाल है। हॉस्पिटल के नाम पर AIIMS इत्यादि बना तो दिए गए हैं, मगर आपको जरूरत पड़ने पर गोरखपुर, पटना आदि जगहों पर स्पेशलिस्ट डॉक्टर ही नहीं मिलेंगे, क्योंकि उनकी पोस्टिंग ही नहीं हुई है। मजबूरन सामान्य लोगों को प्राइवेट का ही मुंह देखना पड़ता है। मेडिकल इंश्योरेंस लो तो क्लेम देने में आनाकानी होती है। आयुष्मान कार्ड का कॉन्सेप्ट बढ़िया है, पर ये सबके लिए नहीं है। जिनके लिए है, उनका कैसा चल रहा है, इसका मुझे ज्यादा अनुभव नहीं है। तो कुल मिलाकर बात ये है कि उपरोक्त चीज़ें बेसिक वाली हैं, जो हम-आप सबके आम जीवन से जुड़ी हुई हैं। इनको एड्रेस किए बगैर लोगों की जिंदगी आसान कभी नहीं हो सकती। आम आदमी को सिर्फ़ नौकरी और सैलरी नहीं चाहिए। उसे ऐसी व्यवस्था चाहिए, जिसमें काम करने के बाद जिंदगी जीने का भी समय हो, बच्चों की अच्छी शिक्षा हो, इलाज़ के लिए घर-जमीन न बेचनी पड़े और भविष्य को लेकर थोड़ी सामाजिक सुरक्षा हो। यही असली सवाल हैं, जिन पर बात होनी चाहिए।
28
386
2
696
21,636
मेरी सरकार आयी तो UPI-सूपिआई बंद कर चमड़े से सिक्के चलाउंगा। चमड़े जनता के ही होंगे। जो अपनी जितनी चमड़ी उतरवा सकेगा, उसके पास उतने सिक्के होंगे। तथास्तु
116
811
21
4,913
86,505
India mein koi 5 minutes number Google kar le to doodh ka doodh paani ka paani ho jaye. RBI surplus to Govt : ₹2.87 Lakh Crores (US$30 Bn) Total listed bank profits : ₹4.11 Lakh Crores (US$42 Bn) NPCI - which runs UPI pre tax ‘surplus’ : ₹ 1,888 crores (US$200 Mn) To nuksaan kis ka ho raha hai UPI se aur kaunsi subsidy de rahi hai Govt UPI pe jo chubh rahi hai? Cost of running ATMs and cash logistics in India is ₹30,500 crores (US$ 3.0 Bn). If you want to optimise shut ATMs and promote UPI instead. Any levy on UPI is just tax collection. UPI is the one scientific achievement of India everyone acknowledges par ab tax ki bali chadhegi.
UPI Charges Row | Ashneer Grover Exclusive If I transfer ₹1 lakh to my friend through UPI, or I pay ₹3,000 using a QR code, what is the cost of running the system? The cost is the same. So, if I transfer ₹1 lakh to my friend, nobody is making money from it. But if I make a payment of ₹2,500 to a small shopkeeper then the government wants to put charges, what’s the logic? — @Ashneer_Grover speaks to @shreyadhoundial
1,874
14,981
600
59,332
4,400,674
Oblivious retweeted
427
29,607
612
154,183
1,959,068
Request to PM & FM for implementing 5 Days banking a week. #5DayBanking @PMOIndia @nsitharaman @RBI
63
742
12
1,628
31,252