RightToCompute (@RightToCompute) header
RightToCompute (@RightToCompute) profile picture

Advocating for everyone’s #RightToCompute 🧮🗽

Joined January 2024
This Silicon Valley Podcast interview with Arto Bendiken reminds us of our debt of gratitude to the cypherpunks, warriors who arose in the 1990s Crypto Wars but who remain relevant today. "Cypherpunks are that original group of all American technologists and entrepreneurs who brought us publicly accessible cryptography... The cypherpunks are responsible for bringing us secure communications in general, secure internet browsing (also known as SSL or TLS), the Tor Project, Bitcoin itself, PGP, encrypted email, and many, many more things that we just wouldn't have without this activism." The Right to Compute applies to many areas, but privacy came first.
4
3
14
1,729
Cinemas today get their movies as a Digital Cinema Package—encrypted files (100–500 GB) delivered on a hard drive or via satellite. President Trump's plan to impose a 100% tariff on foreign-made movies echoes the Crypto Wars of decades past, when the US Government tried to restrict other digital exports and imports, and failed on freedom-of-speech grounds. Cypherpunks might offer a modest proposal: instead of restricting the inflow of digital content, Trump could merely revoke its copyright protection.
Replying to @NicoPerrino
President Trump's "national security" claim suggests he's assuming authority under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, which he used to justify his earlier tariffs (even though the IEEPA doesn't explicitly mention a tariff power). But as @Will_Duffield points out, the IEEPA was amended in 1988 and 94 to prohibit regulating "informational materials" under the IEEPA. So Trump's tariff on foreign films is likely prohibited by the Constitution and federal statute.
1
1
4
238
We’re going to need a Boom Overture route between Billings and Manchester, and any other techno-optimist clusters. Consider it, New Hampshire Emerging Tech Caucus. @EmergingTechNH
Rep. Ammon commented, “Congratulations to Senator Zolnikov and the Montana Legislature for being the first to establish the ‘right to compute’ in law! ... I expect other states to follow your lead and protect citizens' right to access and express themselves through computation.”
1
7
377
With the signing of SB 212, the 'Right to Compute Act', Montana just became the first state in the US—and probably the first place in the world—to recognize computation as a human right. Thanks and congratulations, Senator Daniel Zolnikov!
1
8
1
24
2,740
In this op-ed for the New Hampshire Union Leader, Rep. Keith Ammon and #RightToCompute activist Stephen Cobb address two RTC questions: wherefrom and how? 1. Is the right to compute a brand-new right, or a technological extension of preexisting rights? 2. Should the right to compute be defined generally, or should its specific applications be listed? @RepKeithAmmon @UnionLeader
1
6
14
877
Instead of promoting a general #RightToCompute, Idaho politicians have been taking a narrower approach to protect the right of specific compute uses. In 2024, Idaho State Sen. Scott Herndon (member of the Idaho Freedom Caucus @FreedomCaucusID) sponsored the S1296 Bitcoin Protection Act ("Distributed Ledger Technology"), narrowly defeated 17-18. Today, Idaho State Sen. Ben Toews is sponsoring S1067 "AI regulation limitations": "Recognizing that computation is a form of personal expression, this legislation protects free speech by prohibiting governmental entities from regulating artificial intelligence in various ways, thereby keeping the development of the technology open to everyone." The Idaho Freedom Foundation @idahofreedom gives it their thumbs-up. One could call Idaho the 2½th RTC state.
1
1
4
197
The most provocative question of the Right to Compute bill hearing was posed by Rep. Donald McFarlane @donald4nh: "What are your thoughts on a possible amendment to the [Right to Compute] article proposed here that would address [encryption] as part of this right?" On the one hand, a constitutional provision should not be written cryptically (e.g, “A well regulated Militia”). On the other hand, it should not be in legalese, but be concise and eloquent. But it’s difficult to predict how future citizens will interpret our original intent. The Right to Compute applies to all uses of computation that do not infringe on the rights of others, e.g. encryption, blockchain, and AI. The list will no doubt grow—does it make sense to enumerate them? As the Right to Comptue is a technological extension of the freedom of thought, perhaps encryption is a technological extension of the right to privacy. Thoughts, @EFF?
Interesting and constructive discussion in New Hampshire’s Right to Compute bill (CACR6) Judiciary Committee hearing. Sponsor @RepKeithAmmon focused his testimony on government attempts to regulate AI, but committee members brought up the areas of digital privacy and blockchain. One committee member noted the twin threats of excess electricity consumption and noise production—exactly the bogeymen used to justify regulating data centers prejudicially. Another committee member focused on whether the right to compute should be defined concisely and broadly (the current language) or be supplemented with specific areas like digital privacy. It’s the first half hour starting here: youtube.com/live/EFb6GsQclz8… to 34:46
1
5
137
Interesting and constructive discussion in New Hampshire’s Right to Compute bill (CACR6) Judiciary Committee hearing. Sponsor @RepKeithAmmon focused his testimony on government attempts to regulate AI, but committee members brought up the areas of digital privacy and blockchain. One committee member noted the twin threats of excess electricity consumption and noise production—exactly the bogeymen used to justify regulating data centers prejudicially. Another committee member focused on whether the right to compute should be defined concisely and broadly (the current language) or be supplemented with specific areas like digital privacy. It’s the first half hour starting here: youtube.com/live/EFb6GsQclz8… to 34:46
5
4
4
36
18,398
New Hampshire’s Right to Compute bill CACR6 has a Judiciary committee hearing at 09:30 on Wednesday, 12 February, in LOB Room 206-208. Supporters who can appear in person, please come testify!
CACR6. A right to compute our founding fathers would have recognized had they been alive today.
3
5
1
23
2,474
Data Privacy Day is a good occasion to remember that your digital rights depend on your right to compute—without it, you will end up manipulated, exploited, and poor. It's also a good occasion to support the Electronic Frontier Foundation @EFF. #DataPrivacyDay 🤫🔏🔒
5
1
18
1,842
“In its last days in office, the Biden Administration seeks to undermine America’s leadership with a 200+ page regulatory morass, drafted in secret and without proper legislative review” - NVIDIA on the Biden AI export control restrictions announced this morning Tbh, these words are way too polite…
2
136
Replying to @TheFIREorg
This quote by Benjamin Franklin is displayed on a wall of the Capitol Building. Computation is not merely expression, but thought itself. It augments human thought like the printing press does speech. The #RightToCompute can be based on the freedom of thought, a right so obvious that it was not included in the Bill of Rights, though it is explicitly defined in the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights and the European Convention on Human Rights.
1
4
62
Replying to @beffjezos
Unlocking potential synergy
23
Replying to @deanwball
@deanwball got this shoutout from @DarioAmodei as the 'one guy' with a rational approach to regulation: "I think those were mostly nonsense, but there are better arguments against regulation. There's one guy, Dean Ball, who's really, I think, a very scholarly analyst who looks at what happens when a regulation is put in place and ways that they can kind of get a life of their own, or how they can be poorly designed. And so our interest has always been, we do think there should be regulation in this space, but we want to be an actor who makes sure that that regulation is something that's surgical, that's targeted at the serious risks and is something people can actually comply with. Because something I think the advocates of regulation don't understand as well as they could is if we get something in place that is poorly targeted, that wastes a bunch of people's time, what's gonna happen is people are gonna say, see, these safety risks, this is nonsense. I just had to hire 10 lawyers to fill out all these forms. I had to run all these tests for something that was clearly not dangerous. And after six months of that, there will be a groundswell and we'll end up with a durable consensus against regulation. And so I think the worst enemy of those who want real accountability is badly designed regulation. We need to actually get it right. If there is one thing I could say to the advocates, it would be that I want them to understand this dynamic better, and we need to be really careful and we need to talk to people who actually have experience seeing how regulations play out in practice. And the people who have seen that understand to be very careful. If this was some lesser issue, I might be against regulation at all. But what I want the opponents to understand is that the underlying issues are actually serious. They’re not something that I or the other companies are just making up because of regulatory capture. They're not sci-fi fantasies. They're not any of these things. Every time we have a new model, every few months, we measure the behavior of these models and they're getting better and better at these concerning tasks, just as they are getting better and better at good, valuable, economically useful tasks."
1
1
3
129
Replying to @beffjezos
With axe and sword, strike the root.
1
30