Benjamin Doxtdator (@doxtdatorb) header
Benjamin Doxtdator (@doxtdatorb) profile picture

Haudenosaunee/ Oneida Nation / Dad / Teacher/ views own / I'm w @learn_thru_it / header Fre Sonneveld / he, him, his

Hamilton, Ontario
Joined February 2014
Photo by Benjamin Doxtdator (@doxtdatorb)Photo by Benjamin Doxtdator (@doxtdatorb)Photo by Benjamin Doxtdator (@doxtdatorb)Photo by Benjamin Doxtdator (@doxtdatorb)Photo by Benjamin Doxtdator (@doxtdatorb)Photo by Benjamin Doxtdator (@doxtdatorb)Photo by Benjamin Doxtdator (@doxtdatorb)Photo by Benjamin Doxtdator (@doxtdatorb)Photo by Benjamin Doxtdator (@doxtdatorb)Photo by Benjamin Doxtdator (@doxtdatorb)
You know that factoid about 65% of kids working in jobs not yet invented? Here's the sixty year history. longviewoneducation.org/fiel…
35
309
91
495
A special education/math education professor on the historical legacy of Project Follow Through (not quite the same story that is being gleefully spun in media right now) mathematizing4all.com/2026/1…
2
1
6
413
Benjamin Doxtdator retweeted
It might be my imagination but it feels like those who are vocally pro AI schools seem to have quite a low opinion of teachers generally. I know a lot of extremely effective teachers. AI definitely has a place in teaching but a silver bullet? I'm far from convinced.
5
5
23
755
Benjamin Doxtdator retweeted
I've used an inclusion rider in my contract since April 2019 and I wanted to share eight reactions I've gotten to it from organizations that have asked me to work with them. Sometimes it was well received and sometimes not. Read more here: robertkaplinsky.com/eight-re…
1
1
6
1,181
Benjamin Doxtdator retweeted
beyond the obvious pedagogical flaws with teaching scripts, remember that they are generally produced by transnational corporations who generate serious economic profit for themselves by (wrongly) convincing teachers that scripts make teaching more equitable and efficient.
Actors use scripts. Musicians use sheet music. Surgeons follow established procedures. Why are scripts for teachers treated as an affront to professionalism? @ehanford explains why Direct Instruction uses them.
17
36
3
246
17,800
I haven't seen anyone who argues curriculums privilege knowledge of dominant culture and argue for inclusion of perspectives that have been marginalized, e.g. perspectives of Indigenous people, then say we should bypass knowledge because we can't agree and just teach 21c skills.
Replying to @ehanford
@ehanford’s Season 2 of #SoldAStory is a wrap (for now) so it’s a good time for us to have the long overdue conversation about the relative effectiveness of different instructional approaches. Doing so will trip a wire though and I wrote about this late last year. Is conveying knowledge core business for schools? Many think not, which goes some way towards explaining their antipathy to Direct/direct/explicit instruction. Welcome to SPOCK: The Society for the Prevention of Children’s Knowledge. share.google/gfbUaeFOGkpbacS…
3
1
4
249
That seems to conflate people who would align themselves w Critical Pedagogy / Culturally Sustaining teaching with the OECD.
1
35
Benjamin Doxtdator retweeted
Grim reading, to be honest. It feels like we're ushering in a Big Tech takeover of one of the last bastions of meaningful human connection: education. Another opportunity to commodify something that should be a public good. There's an underlying assumption here that AI will inevitably be smarter than humans, so why bother with human teachers at all? But surely education is about much more than delivering information efficiently? Young people are completely right to be suspicious of Big Tech, its resource hungry data centres and the enormous power concentrated in private hands. And now education is next on the menu. Health, education, human interaction itself.. is there anything the billionaire class won't try to turn into a market? The question I'd ask is who actually benefits from all this? And at what point do we stop asking whether AI can replace teachers and start asking what we lose when it does? 🤷🏻‍♂️
9
12
4
43
4,903
Benjamin Doxtdator retweeted
Voyager 1 was a beast. How insane is it that in 1977 we launched a probe that would end up traveling over one light day from earth! It’s been almost 50 years and we haven’t topped that. Yet
On Feb. 14, 1990, Voyager 1 looked back from beyond Neptune and photographed Earth as a pale blue dot, a speck about a pixel wide in a ray of sunlight. Then it turned its cameras off for good, and kept going.
47
836
63
4,107
276,125
Benjamin Doxtdator retweeted
This is worth reading. The first part is particularly wild
Part 2 of my reporting on Alpha School--this one focusing on why @C_Hendrick, a founding member of its Learning Science Team, came to believe that AI-powered tech can do a better job of delivering instruction than human teachers. Part 3 is coming soon. nataliewexler.substack.com/p…
3
1
8
2,600
Benjamin Doxtdator retweeted
I have long accused the Alpha "learning scientists" and their allies of being a self-referential in group who derives power from appeals to authority and stories they tell themselves about themselves rather than evidence. Wexler's Vaites-inspired Alpha hagiography is Exhibit A.
2
3
26
1,444
Benjamin Doxtdator retweeted
parent story 👇
Replying to @BillAckman
My son attended Alpha from 2020 until recently. Most of the families in our original cohort have pulled their kids over the past two years. Alpha has slick marketing, but there’s been a lot of dysfunction behind the scenes. These are things I personally observed: 1. Persistent teacher turnover. 2. Alpha created a “Dean of Parents” role that acts as a gatekeeper between parents and guides. Direct parent–guide interaction is strongly discouraged. 3. A guide at Alpha’s main campus was disciplined and ultimately fired, in part, for telling a parent that their child was crying daily due to frustration with trying to complete their work in 2 hours. The parent appreciated the transparency. The Dean of Parents objected and attempted to block a scheduled meeting between her and the guide to focus on helping the child. 4. The two-hour academic promise doesn’t hold for most students. Many children struggle to finish their work, some cry regularly, and negative self-talk is common. From what I saw, only about 15–20% of students had an “Epic Day” where all academics were completed. Many kids end up finishing work at home. 5.There’s implicit pressure on kids and parents to speak positively about the school. Alpha does some things well. They have big aspirations. But right now, the hype doesn’t match the reality. I wish them the best.
2
6
40
14,068
Benjamin Doxtdator retweeted
Bad schools “aren’t the biggest threat to poor children.” No district/country has achieved 100% proficiency. Even if we did, we’d have proficient kids working at WalMart. More importantly, smart poor kids have worse outcomes than low- scoring rich kids. Inequality is the problem!
1
12
27
857
Benjamin Doxtdator retweeted
Nice paper by Megan Selbach-Allen, @joboaler and others on Gray and Tall's work on high- and low-attainers math strategies: link.springer.com/article/10…. Of note are the cautious conclusions, good discussion of limitations, and Bonferroni corrections for multiple comparisons (Yay!)
3
6
32
4,117
Benjamin Doxtdator retweeted
Project Follow Through is often cited as proof Direct Instruction “beat” inquiry. But is that the whole story? What Project Follow Through Does (and Doesn’t) Tell Us About Inquiry: wegrowteachers.com/what-proj…
1
3
6
300
Benjamin Doxtdator retweeted
What does Direct Instruction actually look like? McGraw-Hill's sample math lesson scripts both the teacher's questions and students' expected responses. That's what Sold a Story is discussing. Would you want to teach math this way? robertkaplinsky.com/fact-che…
17
4
23
6,238
Benjamin Doxtdator retweeted
Replying to @BuckPatric20223
Spelling helps to reinforce the reading if it’s done correctly. But most of the time it is random word lists. We’ve got to stop with 90 min literacy blocks just being memorizing phonics rules!
2
2
20
624