Dr. Edo S. Jaya (@edoyap) header
Dr. Edo S. Jaya (@edoyap) profile picture

Founder of IndoPsyCare (Indonesian Psychological Healthcare Center) Editor-in-Chief Makara Human Behavior Studies in Asia

Jakarta, Indonesia
Joined March 2012
Photo by Dr. Edo S. Jaya (@edoyap)Photo by Dr. Edo S. Jaya (@edoyap)Photo by Dr. Edo S. Jaya (@edoyap)Photo by Dr. Edo S. Jaya (@edoyap)Photo by Dr. Edo S. Jaya (@edoyap)Photo by Dr. Edo S. Jaya (@edoyap)
Dr. Edo S. Jaya retweeted
4 years ago the 988 National Suicide Prevention Hotline was rolled out to great fanfare. $4 billion later, the effects appear to be a resounding ..."womp womp." An NBER working paper finds that hotline operations have been substantially expanded, but nonetheless saw no detectable reduction in suicide mortality, per @PatrickNDempsey, who has firsthand experience at a call center. No improvements were found in other population mental health outcomes, either. It's been an earnest effort, but fed and state govt's must acknowledge the evidence and redirect attention and funding toward other potential solutions that could be more effective. Impressive of Dempsey to take such a clear-eyed view. mises.org/mises-wire/988-may…
8
13
6
67
10,905
Dr. Edo S. Jaya retweeted
The history of psychiatry is littered with fad diagnoses used to explain otherwise unexplainable distress or disturbing behavior. Current favorites are ADHD & Autism with exploding rates triggered by internet self-diagnosis. Any diagnosis that purports to explain everything explains nothing.
Un fenómeno clínico cada vez más observado: algunas personas con rasgos de trastornos de personalidad del grupo B (como el límite o el narcisista), que implican patrones de inestabilidad emocional, impulsividad o conductas explotadoras, prefieren atribuir esos comportamientos a diagnósticos como TDAH o autismo porque estos últimos cargan con menos estigma y se asocian a la idea de “neurodivergencia”. En la práctica vemos que ciertos pacientes, especialmente mujeres jóvenes con alto nivel educativo y mucha actividad en redes sociales, llegan a consulta ya convencidos de que tienen TDAH o TEA y buscan la confirmación de ese diagnóstico, a veces después de haber rechazado previamente un diagnóstico de trastorno de personalidad. Un estudio reciente con psicólogos clínicos confirma que TDAH y autismo son precisamente los diagnósticos más buscados o autodiagnosticados en esta población, lo que puede dificultar una evaluación precisa y el tratamiento adecuado de los problemas de base.
22
33
5
208
9,937
ADHD & ASD were most frequently identified as self-diagnosed or desired...[by people] commonly described as female, highly educated, & strongly engaged in online activities...[this was explained] mainly in terms of relief from guilt, identity affirmation, and social recognition. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4155…
14
52
13
321
17,505
Guys someone is impersonating me. Tolong bantu blok dan report ya.
1
35
Dr. Edo S. Jaya retweeted
Biological psychiatry, a total failure. Thomas Insel, the director of the US National Institute of Mental Health from 2002 to 2015, said in an interview in 2017: “I spent 13 years at NIMH really pushing on the neuroscience and genetics of mental disorders, and when I look back on that I realize that while I think I succeeded at getting lots of really cool papers published by cool scientists at fairly large costs - I think $20 billion - I don’t think we moved the needle in reducing suicide, reducing hospitalizations, improving recovery for the tens of millions of people who have mental illness. I hold myself accountable for that.” bit.ly/3Vs7fGH
68
329
66
1,250
85,400
Dr. Edo S. Jaya retweeted
Another large study finds ADHD meds don't improve school performance, at least for kids on the margin of treatment. I remain unsure what ADHD is. I was taught it was a delay in maturation that resolved. Later, a lifelong disorder of attention. More recently, a problem of alertness and reward pathways more than attention. Either way, parents and teachers often push medication hoping to improve grades. This study looked at all children aged 5 to 15 in Norway. It used differences in how clinics prescribe as a natural experiment. Using this analysis academic benefits of medication disappeared. "For children and adolescents on the margin of pharmacological treatment for ADHD, we found no causal effect of pharmacological treatment on any of our measures of academic performance." DOI: 10.1192/bjp.2026.10754 Picture: Figure 2(b) showing that GPA doesn’t significantly increase with meds using the instrumental variable analysis.
40
43
12
202
20,803
Dr. Edo S. Jaya retweeted
idntimes.com/news/indonesia/… Listyo Sigit Prabowo, Ahrie Sonta dan Eko Hadi ditetapkan sebagai tersangka dugaan penyadapan presiden
132
607
102
1,757
94,064
Dr. Edo S. Jaya retweeted
Kas perusahaan sebaiknya disimpan saja atau bisa dikelola agar lebih produktif? Simak pengalaman Dr. Phil. Edo S. Jaya, M.Psi., Psikolog, Founder IndoPsyCare, dalam mengatur dana operasional, menjaga likuiditas, dan memanfaatkan reksa dana melalui Bareksa Bisnis. 🎧youtu.be/Zh25_r9lKg8
1
1
625
Dr. Edo S. Jaya retweeted
Human emotional distress is ubiquitous. Psychiatric disorder is pretty rare. Conflating them causes big trouble. 30 yrs ago, wild fad psych diagnosis was promoted by Big Pharma/mostly done by the MDs. Internet is now to blame & the loose self labelling is done by the patients.
When a Diagnosis Becomes Just a Word: The Problem of Popularized Mental Health Words versus Professional Diagnoses. Psychiatric diagnoses are unusually vulnerable to popularization and misuse. Most people don’t casually diagnose each other with liver disease or orthopedic disorders. But mental-health concepts describe experiences woven into everyday life—mood, attention, personality, relationships, behavior. That familiarity creates an illusion of expertise. A carefully defined clinical construct becomes a familiar word, and the word gradually gets mistaken for the construct itself.
4
22
4
86
19,312
Dr. Edo S. Jaya retweeted
Some of the numbers in this are wild. Stimulant prescriptions for ADHD up 29% in one year. This is a prescribing cascade. It would worry me far less if people were being given honest information about the causes of ADHD and the risks of the drugs. But, as recent discourse on this site has shown, people are fiercely committed to the idea that ADHD is caused by a brain difference and implacably hostile to anyone exploring alternative, more plausible explanations.
15
23
3
84
7,714
The ODESSI trial is finally published. The headline findings are: The odds of being admitted to hospital for severe mental illness was three times less for those who had Open Dialogue compared to standard care, reducing the use of hospital by 54%. The chance of being referred to a crisis service was halved for those who had Open Dialogue compared to standard care. Patient-defined recovery (people's rating of their own relationships, work, study and other self-rated markers of recovery) improved for those who had Open Dialogue compared to standard care. There was no statistically significant difference in the time it took to relapse in the Open Dialogue arm of the trial compared with standard care. Overall quality of life was improved for those who had Open Dialogue compared to standard care. Patient experience & rating of the care they received was higher for those who had Open Dialogue compared to standard care. Taken from RCPsych reporting (link below) Link to BBC article also below. Congrats to Profs Razzaque and Pilling
9
43
7
86
11,778
Dr. Edo S. Jaya retweeted
Don't diagnose ADHD if: 1)onset wasn't in childhood 2)symptoms are better accounted for by another psych diagnosis (all can cause inattention) 3)impairment/distress isnt clinically significant 4)symptoms occur only in chaotic environments Watchful waiting beats rush to diagnose
Replying to @AllenFrancesMD
How do you best distinguish between normal distracted (met their limit intellectually, busy, poor habits, etc.) and ADHD? I think that it is easier in other disorders where the problematic thing is an excess not a deficiency, e.g. anxiety. Too much anxiety is when it is counter
24
56
9
333
44,772
Huhu.. Jam 6 tadi, SIAK-NG udah say bye, gengs 🥲
102
940
895
3,717
397,418
Dr. Edo S. Jaya retweeted
Sadly this what I and others have been predicting for a couple of decades. As a concept it is past its use by date. Anyone can have autism now, says research pioneer telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/08…
26
27
5
101
9,735
Dr. Edo S. Jaya retweeted
ADHD diagnoses up 93% in less than 10 years. At this rate, we can reach 50% of kids diagnosed by 2050 and 100% by 2090. I am being somewhat silly. Kids struggling with attention sucks and parents feel powerless. Sometimes we can't find solutions in the office to big problems: societal, educational, abuse. Yet a doubling of the diagnosis in 10 years is something that warrants serious consideration and reflection.
19
17
7
63
7,505
After years of hard work I am pleased to say I have finally been featured on the cover of Men's Health... ... ...in the story in the bottom left about the difficulties of stopping antidepressants
24
28
6
250
7,565