Pinned Tweet
Returning altar rails, ad orientem, decent vestments, Gregorian chant, throwing in a bit of incense, doing away with altar girls as well as Bob and Susan at Communion et al: all that can serve to make the NO less intolerable, sure, but it can't fix THE problem, the Original Sin of the liturgical upheaval we're all living though, which is the insane rejection of what was received and handed down through the centuries, the ancient rituals and ceremonies which Latin rite Catholics are as bound to cherish and "own" EVERY BIT as much as, for example, Byzantine Catholics are bound to cherish their liturgical heritage (Divine Liturgy of Saint John Chrysostom). Paul VI (being merely and importantly the Pope) had absolutely no right to discard and replace it, on the contrary he was bound to defend it with his lifeblood, and to do everything for its preservation. Ditto a Council of the Church. That's my conviction. When sanity is restored to the Church, I cannot bring myself to doubt that it will be the prevailing view.
Gary Paul H retweeted
Altar Mitty
The Reich Reverend
Sermon Göring
Heinrich Hymnler
Any other suggestions?
lol, just as long as the “deeper, painful human motivations” of those with trad leanings are disregarded
A rush to faithfully comply with the rubrics would only paper over the deeper, painful human motivations that underlie the “liturgy wars.”
americamagazine.org/short-ta…
27
Gary Paul H retweeted
Most people know that St. Thomas Aquinas rejected St. Anselm’s ontological argument for the existence of God. Far fewer know that his great contemporary, St. Bonaventure, not only defended the argument but developed a sophisticated philosophical account of it that addresses all six of Aquinas’s objections.
By drawing upon Aristotelian logic, the metaphysics of divine simplicity, and his understanding of God as being itself (ipsum esse), Bonaventure explains why God’s existence is a self-evident and indubitable truth.
Interestingly, Bonaventure’s earlier treatment actually precedes that of Aquinas. He was not writing a direct rebuttal of Aquinas, yet his reasoning provides an answer to each of the objections Aquinas would make famous.
This is one of the most important and neglected developments in the history of the ontological argument.
Here is a graphic from my forthcoming book summarizing Bonaventure’s answers to all six objections, along with their primary textual sources.
Peter Hitchens sampling GTA is exactly as you’d expect it to be (and I must say I agree with him !).
Gary Paul H retweeted
You couldn't make this stuff up.
This is such an unbelievably lame attempt to capture the fictional “every day racism” that doesn’t actually exist in the real world, it doesn’t even rise to the level of piss poor caricature. Good old Corrie, bravely tackling the rise of the mythical Far Right!
The conditioning was on another level at the start of this episode of Coronation Street. This is like a comedy sketch show. “We’ve got ourselves a funny one.” The main “racist” is hilarious. I can’t believe ITV put this out on TV.
52
Seeing samples of GTA 6 that all the gaming nerds are peeing their pants about. Not exactly wholesome, morally beautiful stuff. Just an observation!
40
Yes you guessed it. This bishop — here boring on about pastoral accompaniment to all manner of fruity stuff — has severely restricted the TLM in his diocese of Münster. It’s the one exception to their synodal accompaniment thing, you see.
Bishop Wilmer comments again on the recent Amoris Laetitia mtg
Re cohabitation of un-married couples:
“there was great unanimity at the bishops' meeting: We need a different language here that makes it clear: We do not condemn this, but we accompany you on the path to marriage.”
Communion for divorced & re-married:
“There were differing opinions on this. The final text is not yet available. In my perception, the majority was of the opinion that we need good pastoral solutions for the local people.”
Most notable his reply to 2nd question, given that he is not simply defaulting to repeating what Pope Francis wrote in AL, suggesting that bishops sensed a different move is coming from Pope Leo
Soon on @CatholicHerald
1
97
Meanwhile in Novus Ordo Land
Bishop Wilmer comments again on the recent Amoris Laetitia mtg
Re cohabitation of un-married couples:
“there was great unanimity at the bishops' meeting: We need a different language here that makes it clear: We do not condemn this, but we accompany you on the path to marriage.”
Communion for divorced & re-married:
“There were differing opinions on this. The final text is not yet available. In my perception, the majority was of the opinion that we need good pastoral solutions for the local people.”
Most notable his reply to 2nd question, given that he is not simply defaulting to repeating what Pope Francis wrote in AL, suggesting that bishops sensed a different move is coming from Pope Leo
Soon on @CatholicHerald
1
31
Gary Paul H retweeted
Replying to @ChristineNiles1
But a bishop shouldn’t have to ask for a carve out to celebrate a licit and holy rite -like any other rite in the Church. Traditionis Custodes was a malicious piece of legislation that abrogated the pastoral wisdom of Pope Benedict and ushered in a period of liturgical suspicion and chaos. In some dioceses this continues. We hear endless talk of “walking with the faithful”. But the faithful attached to the ancient Latin rite are treated like lepers and banished from their own parishes. A parish priest can no longer respond to his own people. And if the Bishop, who hasn’t been trained in the traditional Latin Mass or has no affinity for it wishes to stamp it out, suddenly the church doesn’t care to walk or talk with those people. Benedict rightly liberated the traditional Latin Mass, and it was flourishing wherever the people yearned for sacrality and reverence. It was working beautiful. Pope Francis‘s legislation was a rupture-unnecessary and cruel. This fanatical demand that all conform to one rite will not create unity. It only foments division and hard feelings. Worship of God should be encouraged, especially in its traditional and venerable forms.
Gary Paul H retweeted
“Having rejected Francis and being anxious now to accept Leo, these folks have only two options: humility (I guess I may have been wrong about Francis) or a lie (Leo is correcting Francis). Only one of these is Christian.”
But Dr Ivereigh is fine with “correcting Benedict.”
Gary Paul H retweeted
For those upset about Leo refusing to let you have the Latin Mass, he is still offering this, if it’s any consolation.
#LegacyOfStPaulVI #MaliciousMontini
Hard to comprehend that this barrel of easy going sunshine and laughs has blocked me on Twitter 🤔
“Do you have any worries about speaking to me now?”
“Yeah… it definitely impacts on my career”
Comedian Kate Smurthwaite shares her concerns about calling out inappropriate behaviour in Comedy.
#Newsnight
Yeah, SP undermined Church unity. And TC wondrously restored it. SMH
The pope said such changes would undermine Church unity. He also discussed his recent cancer surgery and the U.S. midterms.
ewtnnews.com/vatican/pope-le…
29
And that’s all I’ve got to say about that
And SP was the decision of Pope Benedict. It brought peace in its wake. It tempered more extreme tendencies that come with being isolated and othered. It was an enriching and positive move. SP v TC is the sun and wind competing to get man to remove coat, in reverse order. TC, issued by F *while BXVI was still alive*, was based on lies (the bishops are getting tired of those pesky trads!) coming as it did from the father of lies. It brought contention and strife and opened old wounds. Above all it was cruel and callous. As impolitic as immoral. It is from hell. And Pope Leo has taken the side of TC>SP. Shame on him.
22





















