James Annable (@jimma54) header
James Annable (@jimma54) profile picture

Composer loves spatial audio (Dolby Atmos) respectful debate only. Listen to my latest work Diana's Mirror https://xitter.gq/t.co/iLiOJw0lOm

Joined June 2009
Photo by James Annable (@jimma54)Photo by James Annable (@jimma54)Photo by James Annable (@jimma54)Photo by James Annable (@jimma54)Photo by James Annable (@jimma54)Photo by James Annable (@jimma54)Photo by James Annable (@jimma54)Photo by James Annable (@jimma54)Photo by James Annable (@jimma54)Photo by James Annable (@jimma54)
Caligula's madness, available on all major streaming platforms. modernclassicalx.lnk.to/Dian… #music #originalmusic #ClassicalMusic
12
1,741
James Annable retweeted
How is this guy a Professor? Embarrassing. It's not defaming someone to express an honest opinion, which I've done with Tait. To make it clear: in my opinion, Tait is Islamophobic. I know our discourse is in the toilet when it comes to Muslims in public life, but here's a handy PSA about anti-Muslim racism. If someone repeatedly calls Muslim politicians "Islamists" without any evidence beyond their ethnicity and religion, that is racist and Islamophobic. Islamist is a slur - it means someone who wants to replace democracy with theocracy and rejects democratic norms. It is obviously defamatory to accuse Muslim politicians who explicitly reject Islamism of being Islamists. If you combined Islamist with extremist, you are then saying they want to replace democracy with theocracy AND want to achieve those ends through extreme measures like violence. You are getting extremely close to calling that person an Islamic fundamentalist who would support the use of political violence like terrorism. I'm not making this up. The UK government literally defines the terms Islamist and extremist. The 2026 UK government paper "Protecting what Matters," published with a foreword by Keir Starmer, defines Islamism as follows: "Islamism is a political ideology; its proponents seek to impose their interpretation of religion and ‘sharia’ as law by state power, and, in various manifestations, justify acts of terror to achieve their goal of a global Islamist state – their version of a ‘caliphate’ or ‘Islamic state’. Islamists do not represent the Muslim communities of the UK." The UK government formally defined extremism in 2024. This is the definition: "Extremism is the promotion or advancement of an ideology based on violence, hatred or intolerance, that aims to: - negate or destroy the fundamental rights and freedoms of others; -or undermine, overturn or replace the UK’s system of liberal parliamentary democracyand democratic rights; - or intentionally create a permissive environment for others to achieve the results in (1) or (2)." "Islamist" and "extremist" ACTUALLY mean something - they're not just descriptors like creepy or gross. They are factual statements about a person's beliefs, views and philosophy, and are plainly defamatory if they are untrue and are not reasonably asserted. It is no different to repeatedly calling Jewish people "Zionist supremacists who want to replace our government with a theocracy run on Talmudic principles through violence" without any evidence, simply based on the fact that they are Jewish. It is no different to saying a Hindu politician supports Hindutva terrorism without any evidence beyond the fact that they are Hindu. Tait has repeatedly identified SPECIFIC people who he calls Islamists. He presents no evidence worthy of the name. He calls some people Islamist extremists. I know some of these people and there is not a hint of truth to the allegation, nor is there any reasonable reason to state it. It is WILDLY defamatory to effectively call someone an Islamic fundamentalist who embraces violence to end democracy if it is untrue. So @colwight, seeing as you're so keen to post on this topic in your name, and I'm sure your University has online codes of conduct, do you want to endorse Habibi or not? I'm waiting.
Replying to @pauleholden
Grow up Paul. You’re here complaining about an account calling people antisemitic, extremists, and Islamists (all of which might be true of course), and then you go call the account a troll and Islamophobic. See the irony? Probably not. Are you defaming them. “Mum, someone was mean to me on social media” isn’t grounds for defamation. And you seem to weirdly think Jews can’t be antisemitic. Never heard of self-hate. Holocaust survivors aren’t immune from critique either, and beloved? To who? Everyone? The whole thing is just nothing, and nothing will come of it, apart from maybe some revelations about the network that conspired to dox him. And that network does have some interesting characters in it. Is “interesting characters” defamation btw?
25
136
5
441
10,559
James Annable retweeted
In 2018, hard Brexit ads from a mystery account @mainstreamuk started flooding the internet. Tory MP Damian Collins raised it as eg of how social media platforms are used by unknown actors using untraceable money to undermine our democracy. A year later, Ian Austin, an ex Labour MP later ennobled by Boris Johnson launched a campaign to ‘restore civility’ to politics. He did so by spending £134k on Corbyn attack ads from the same @mainstreamuk account. It was run by a man called Ben Tait who has now been revealed to be an anonymous troll, @habibi_uk. We still have no idea where any of this money came from. To the people defending Ben Tait, you are defending astroturfed fake grassroots campaigns. You are defending the multi-billion social media companies that enable it & profit from it. You are defending a system in which none of us have any idea who is influencing our politics. And, crucially, who is paying. You are defending oligarchy.
Ok. Here’s a new puzzler from those of you following the Habibi scandal. (And yes, it definitely *is* a scandal). How come I was tweeting at @mainstreamuk the campaign we now know he ran way back in 2018? 1/
36
897
16
2,028
37,208
But maybe it’s just a coincidence that ‘Habibi’ & Lord Ian Austin chanced upon a defunct @mainstreamuk Twitter handle? And maybe it’s also a coincidence both @mainstreamuk campaigns run digital political attack ads with unknown funding? 🤷‍♀️ 10/
3
170
1
614
12,881
I think it's important to remember that by August 2018 we were firmly into Corbyn Part II. Part I, 2015–2017, ended with Corbyn almost pulling off an extraordinary electoral upset. Traditionally, sequels suffer from diminishing returns, but for sheer spectacle, Part II was positively The Godfather Part II. This was the period when the British media's traditional monstering of left-wing politicians became something approaching experimental theatre. Corbyn was apparently responsible for the actions, opinions and misdemeanours of practically anyone who had ever occupied the same political postcode. And here comes David Aaronovitch, solemnly explaining that he wasn't associating Corbyn with the Warrington bombing. Good heavens, no! He was merely associating Corbyn with people associated with a group he speculated might have been associated with the bombing. A perfectly innocent observation, naturally. Nothing to see here. It's the political equivalent of a couple trapped in a miserable marriage, communicating exclusively through passive-aggressive remarks about whose turn it was to empty the dishwasher. Except David was doing it with an IRA bombing. The most extraordinary thing about revisiting 2018 is how much of this now reads like political satire. At times I wonder whether David missed his true vocation as the family novelist. Apologies to his brother Ben, who at least has the decency to label his fiction. And eight years later, David is still insisting that everyone has misunderstood him. Of course we understand you, David. That's precisely why we're laughing.
Smears by association, that makes it all better
27
2
79
1,843
James Annable retweeted
Yes, this is a major part of this story. This broader network including habibi, GnasherJew and Labour Against Antisemitism frequently target left-wing Jews like Justin Schlosberg, Andrew Feinstein, Stephen Kapos, Michael Rosen etc. Quite often, when the true identity of these agitator accounts are revealed, they turn out to be run by non-Jews. But this story isn't just some snowflakey reaction to robust online discourse. There are massive real-world implications about how this network operates. First, many of the accounts in this network are anonymous. They say defamatory things about people who cannot defend their reputation - you can't sue anonymous amounts or put social pressure on named individuals to retract defamatory statements. Second, these accounts directly feed into alarmist stories in the right-wing press: the type of story that calls Misam Harriman or Linkeker racist. These are absurdities. It is genuinely absurd that they are being accused of anti-Jew hate. Madness. Yet these accounts provide grist to mill for the press to go after public figures who criticise Israel or challenge the status quo. These stories are important. They send the message to other celebrities or politicians that speaking out, even mildly, about Israel, can see your words taken out of context, driving media coverage, and then driving you out of your job. They also create a sense of ambient, unrelenting crisis; that there is an epidemic of hate seeping into every corner of our society; that it is so pervasive that even the nice guy from the footy has been infected. Most often this becomes coded and couched in Islamophobic terms - just look at how often habibi goes after pro-Gaza Muslims. The right-wing press is adept at using this to feed into broader "clash of civilisation/anti-immigration" rhetoric. This empowers and emboldens the far-right, but also builds elite consent for attacks on civil liberties and protest. Third, the "evidence" these accounts produce feed into formal processes. Labour Party files show that there are loads of complaints submitted to the Labour Party with evidence from Habibi and GnasherJew. Some emails show GnasherJew advising people on complaints. Habibi, using a Gmail address, had complained directly to the Party in certain cases. Mish Rahman has confirmed that candidates were blocked from standing for the Labour Party based on dossiers with Habibi evidence - the Starmerite bureaucracy, which routinely blocked left-wingers for nonsense, were provided with the ammo they needed to transform the Party by habibi and other agitators. This is genuinely mad: anonymous agitator accounts, who code most expressions of pro-Gaza views as hate, and who routinely target left-wing Jews, were being used as the evidential bedrock to decide who could and couldn't be an MP or councillor. Finally, there is the human cost. People's lives have been upended, sometimes destroyed, by this tiny ecosystem. It's sometimes caused real pain. In The Fraud, I used the story of the Jewish Labour Party member Riva Joffe to illustrate this. Joffe was born to parents who fled antisemitic pogroms in Eastern Europe, and who were forced to flee South Africa (where they had settled) because they became anti-apartheid activists. Joffe became a respected psychoanalyst in the UK. In 2021, on her deathbed, she was sent a letter by the Labour Party saying she was being investigated for antisemitism. Her "crime" was to share an invite on Facebook to a BDS event at a university. The complaint was submitted by "David Gordstein" - the made-up identity created by Euan Phillips, a spokesperson for LAAS. Joffe spent her last weeks answering a charge the she was antisemitic, based on a complaint from a made-up identity. Joffe died while under investigation for antisemitism. The Party refused to tell her son if the case had been resolved after she died. If you think any of that is OK, then you need to have your head checked.
A lot of the people habibi and his anonymous network have attacked ARE Jewish — including a Holocaust survivor Stephen Kapos. So I’m hardly outlining a religious, cultural, or ethnic conspiracy, just the knee jerk reaction of journalists too lazy to look deeper
28
522
28
1,122
38,634
James Annable retweeted
Congratulations to Count Binface for securing 9,455 votes against Farage in Clacton, 1,000 times more than against Burnham. Farage by-election stunt hasn't achieved anything. Parliamentary inquiry into his funding continues. The outcome could force another by-election.
152
501
20
1,550
18,033
James Annable retweeted
England councils sold 14,275 social homes in the year to March 2026. Average receipt £112,900. 3452 replacement homes funded. Over 2m sold since the 1980s. Many sold to private landlords, many to councils at a profit. 1.3m waiting list for social homes mortgagestrategy.co.uk/news/…
24
319
14
431
9,861
James Annable retweeted
Shell shifted billions in profits to tax havens. Complex corporate structures, intragroup transactions used to shift profits to the Bahamas and Switzerland. Taxes dodged in many countries, including the UK. Govt inaction is protecting secret subsidies. archive.ph/Cqq2L
49
609
18
887
13,102
Oh dear, just read all the comments, Nigel and reform are toast, I think even the bots have fallen out of love with the grifter and his Ltd company.
If Andy Burnham is serious about putting politics aside to solve Britain’s biggest problems, it’s remarkable that he’s chosen to ignore Reform. He is conspiring behind closed doors with the failed political establishment to foist further tax rises on the country. The fact Ed Davey and Kemi Badenoch are going along with this tells you all you need to know. This is the uniparty in action.
3
1
5
1,194
In 1978 Kate Bush made the allegation that I had a firearm, I find this deeply unsettling as I was only 7. youtu.be/5c_2QlvdTFc?is=cOci…
1
125
James Annable retweeted
City gears up for a fight bank tax under Burnham. Can't recall bankers fighting bailouts, £895bn quantitative easing, hidden subsidies, branch closures, lousy return on savings, profiteering, gambling. It is one-way traffic to protect self-interest. politico.eu/article/uk-banke…
36
714
8
1,356
13,058
James Annable retweeted
Any Burnham says he will stick to the existing fiscal rules. Rules which delivered Potholed roads PFI infrastructure Huge NHS queues Privatisations Poverty Deindustrialisation Lower healthy life expectancy Low investment in productive assets Must change. leftfootforward.org/2026/07/…
69
433
16
753
11,468
James Annable retweeted
Andy Burnham cabinet consists of neoliberal foot-soldiers. All supported Privatisation of the NHS by stealth Greater role for private equity Profiteering Benefit cuts Higher taxes on the poor Erosion of jury trials Damaging fiscal rules What will change? leftfootforward.org/2026/07/…
110
967
45
1,490
23,810
James Annable retweeted
On 22 July, Robert Jenrick posted a short audio clip of Jo White, the new Immigration Minister, captioned as her saying: "I don't care if we stop the boats." The clip was picked up and amplified by Reform UK's official account, which framed it as evidence that Andy Burnham's government "doesn't give a stuff about stopping the boats" and called for a general election. White responded directly, posting the fuller recording the clip had been taken from. In it, she can be heard saying: "I don't care who will stop the boats, but my priority... my focus is to make sure that we stop those boats." The background audio in her version matches the clip Jenrick posted, indicating both are drawn from the same underlying recording. What differs is the editing and the caption: "who will stop" became "if we stop," and the second half of the sentence, where she affirms stopping the boats as her priority, was cut. The audio recording was posted by notorious right-wing purveyors of misinformation and disinformation, Guido Fawkes and Basil The Great, on 11th July 2025. Both Jenrick and Reform UK subsequently deleted their posts. Neither issued a correction or apology. Jenrick was then asked about the episode on TalkTV, in an interview with Jeremy Kyle. That exchange is worth examining closely, because the way he characterised the dispute does more to obscure what happened than to explain it (the transcript is from the interview). To date, Jenrick and Reform UK have not issued an apology. Kyle put the accusation to him plainly: that Jenrick had "doctored" the clip so that White appeared to say the opposite of what she meant. Jenrick's response ran through several distinct moves, each doing different rhetorical work. 1. "It's very confused" — manufacturing ambiguity where none exists. This phrase is the anchor of his entire defence. It does a lot of work precisely because it's vague: it invites the listener to assume there's a genuine, unresolved factual dispute, perhaps a poor recording, or an ambiguous turn of phrase. But "confused" is not an accurate description of a situation where specific words have been swapped for others ("who will" for "if we") and a clarifying second clause has been removed. That isn't ambiguity; it's a checkable, binary fact about what is or isn't on the recording. Framing it as "confused" moves the dispute from the realm of the verifiable into the realm of the unresolvable, which is precisely where a fair-minded-sounding non-denial wants to sit. 2. Recasting the original quote as self-contradictory. Jenrick describes White as appearing to say "with one breath" that she wants to stop the boats, then "with the next breath" that she doesn't care. This is a subtle but important move: he is not describing the edited clip as misleading (which would concede the point), nor defending the edited clip as accurate (which the evidence doesn't support), he is instead relocating the supposed contradiction into White's original, unedited remarks. But the sentence he's characterising ("I don't care who stops them, my priority is that they're stopped") is not contradictory at all. It is a single, coherent statement about not caring which party or government gets credit. The only version in which a contradiction exists is the one Jenrick shared, which removed the words that resolved it. 3. "A perfectly reasonable point... asking her to explain." This reframes an assertion as a question. But the graphic captioned White's words as a direct, declarative quote, presented as fact, not put to her as a query. You cannot retroactively convert a false statement of fact into an open question by describing it that way after the fact. 4. "She says the recording isn't quite right." This line minimises what White actually did. She didn't raise a vague objection about audio quality; she released a recording with matching ambient markers that demonstrates the specific substitution. Describing this as her merely saying the clip "isn't quite right" downgrades a documented discrepancy to the level of a subjective complaint, which then sets up his next move. 5. "Recollections vary... like the royal family". Imho, this is the most consequential sentence in the interview. By invoking Prince Harry's line about the Queen and Meghan Markle, Jenrick reframes what is, in principle, a resolvable factual question (what is on the tape?) as a matter of subjective memory (what do different people recall from a meeting?), which by definition cannot be adjudicated. This is a category substitution: a dispute about the content of a recording (which either does or does not contain certain words) is recast as a dispute about human recollection, which can never be fully settled. It is a rhetorically effective move precisely because "recollections vary" sounds reasonable and humble, while quietly removing the question from the domain where it could actually be checked. 6. Non-response to the fuller quote. When Kyle read White's fuller statement back to him on air ("I don't care who will stop the boats, but my number one priority is to stop those boats") Jenrick did not engage with its content. His reply, "Well, let's see, let's see," treats a piece of evidence directly bearing on the question as if it were still an open, future-tense matter, rather than something to be assessed on the spot. This is a stalling move: it lets him avoid either conceding the point or contesting it with a counter-argument. 7. The core denial. Asked directly whether he'd made a mistake, Jenrick said: "No, I don't think so." Everything else in the interview functions to make that denial sound reasonable, without addressing the specific, checkable claim against him, namely that the clip he posted altered her words in a way that inverted their meaning. Jenrick's manipulative framing lets him appear conciliatory without ever conceding that the original post was inaccurate or that posting it was a misjudgement. Since Ann Widdecombe's murder (described by police as a targeted attack, and now the subject of a counter-terrorism investigation) Jenrick has spoken repeatedly and forcefully about the dangers of political rhetoric, the need for civility in public debate, and the responsibility owed to people in public life who face threats and abuse for their views. He has argued that politicians holding views "outside the mainstream" face heightened risk, and has criticised the government for what he characterises as complacency about the safety of his colleagues. That case is not unreasonable in the abstract. But it sits uneasily next to a documented episode in which he circulated, and Reform UK's official account amplified, a doctored quote attributed to a sitting MP, on one of the most inflammatory issues in British politics, and then, when confronted with clear evidence of the misrepresentation responded not by acknowledging the error but by reframing a checkable fact as an unresolvable dispute about memory. Deleting the post without any correction or apology is not accountability; it is the quiet withdrawal of a claim without ever admitting the claim was false. If dangerous rhetoric on immigration is a genuine concern, and the argument that heated, dehumanising language on this subject has consequences is one Jenrick himself has made in other contexts, then amplifying a false quote from a fellow MP on precisely that subject, and then defending it through rhetorical sleight of hand rather than correction, is difficult to square with that concern. The inconsistency is not that Jenrick worries about MPs' safety; it's that concern for the tone of political debate applies asymmetrically: vocally invoked when the threat is to his own side, and set aside when the tactic in question is his own. Imho, the @HoCStandards should launch a formal investigation. Interview clip: youtube.com/watch?v=0wRTX5xX…
It wasn't just Robert Jenrick who posted then deleted this dangerously irresponsible disinformation. Reform UK are desperate. This follows their irresponsible claims and speculation about political rhetoric and Ann Widdecombe's death. @HoCStandards need an urgent investigation.
24
198
18
399
49,946
Caligula's revenge, available on all major streaming platforms. modernclassicalx.lnk.to/Dian… #music #originalmusic #ClassicalMusic
4
145
James Annable retweeted
Politicians who fanned these flames should hang their heads in shame. Time and again we've seen this story play out. Single incidents used to fuel a far right narrative - and communities across the nation paying the price.
The rioters have set a house on fire in Belfast.
7,534
4,770
516
26,195
1,753,477
Procession of the king, available on all major streaming platforms. modernclassicalx.lnk.to/Dian… #music #originalmusic #ClassicalMusic
1
5
112
Never forget, every piece of hate earns them money, and they love money as much as they love hate.
2
57
Couldn't put it better myself!
Nigel Farage's emergency address to the nation was him exploiting Henry Nowak’s death for his own political gain.
1
2
93
I don't usually repost Katie Hopkins but I'll do this one as its special.
On behalf of their client, Zara Sultana, Bindmans Media and Information Law Practise Group requires that I publish the following statement on X, and that such statement must be clearly visible and pinned to my profile for a continuous period of no less than 24 hours: “On 30 March 2026, I published a post on my X account addressed to Zarah Sultana in which I stated that she encourages and incites violence and is friends with terrorists. Those statements are false. I was wrong and offer my sincere apologies to Ms Sultana for the harm and distress caused to her.” It is my very great pleasure to do this, and I reiterate my sincere and repeated offer to meet with Miss Zara Sultana in person to resolve our differences.
2
123