しまう retweeted
I don't generally enjoy yucking other people's yums, but in this particular case what we're seeing is that for some people Malfoid represents how much stronger the Harry Potter story could have been if one seemingly minor change was made that has these giant ripple effects throughout the books, affecting the story for the better. For other people Malfoid represents a reawakening of fanfiction as a valid medium of storytelling.
For the former sort of people (myself included), Malfoid being part of the story makes the Harry Potter books better because it strengthens the prevalent theme of "love conquers evil" that Rowling had previously written into the books. For us, this is the only change necessary to improve the story, and anything else just feels like fluff to us.
For the latter sort of people, Malfoid is just one really good change among others that could exist. Other changes include Ron x Pansy, Luna Lovegood being a far-right "noticer", Dumbledore abusing Dobby, Hermione being a leftist activist, removing Sectumsempra, and McGonagall being a hardened war hero, just to name a few. Now, most of these are jokes, and some of those jokes are really funny (I particularly enjoy the idea of Luna being far-right and McGonagall being a war hero lol), but the ones that are serious changes (like Ronsy and removing Sectumsempra) are ideas that change the Harry Potter story to the point where it's practically another story altogether. It's at that point where it's the same kind of fanfiction that so many of us never really got super into.
Now, to counter the responses that I anticipate I'll receive, I'm not trying to say that one person is correct and the other is wrong. I'm saying that not everything is for everyone. Thankfully, there is something everyone can agree on: Malfoid is a beautiful character, and the Wizarding World would be better with her in it































































































