Elly Maloba (@malobations) header
Elly Maloba (@malobations) profile picture

Global citizen. Sociologist. Cartoonist. Peacebuilder. Cyclist. T/R ➡️ #ConflictEarlyWarningEarlyResponse #PeacebuildingBigIdeaChallenge2020 Winner

Kenya
Joined January 2011
Photo by Elly Maloba (@malobations)Photo by Elly Maloba (@malobations)Photo by Elly Maloba (@malobations)Photo by Elly Maloba (@malobations)Photo by Elly Maloba (@malobations)Photo by Elly Maloba (@malobations)Photo by Elly Maloba (@malobations)Photo by Elly Maloba (@malobations)Photo by Elly Maloba (@malobations)Photo by Elly Maloba (@malobations)
We cant live like this. We need to start ramping up pressure to GoK bureaucrats and politicians. They walk abroad but here they love cars because in those tinted windows, they're insulated from public scrutiny and the smell of underdevelopment that they make us wallow in.
Pedestrians and cyclists are getting a raw deal on Uhuru Highway.
4
64
2
107
2,045
Elly Maloba retweeted
One thing you have to give to Kasongo. He has made everyone understand governance. Now people understand that politics = governance = way of life.
16
355
8
925
8,935
Elly Maloba retweeted
And then there is GNLD. 3 Days after I cleared campus (8/4/2011), my friend @sankaraobiero and I are invited to some building near Nation Center for a job interview. You know hakuna kitu inaweza kupea hopes kama ukiwa fresh from campus alafu uangukie a "well paying job." Pasi ikapigwa kwa nguo. Long' hata line nzi akipita mbele ama upitishe katarasi mbele itakatwa. Coat pia. Na shirt ya checked ndogo ya Red. Marashi ya Cobra na bahasha iko na documents. Kufika, Red Flag ya kwanza, tukaambiwa we don't need our documents. Red Flag number two. They kept talking about Directors. And Toyota Mark II. And then the final Red Flag....Tukawekwa kwa group tukaambiwa tulips sijui 250. Alafu tutafute 10 people walipe 250 pia ndio tuanze kupata kakitu. Ogopa Nairobi
After uni when I was desperately looking for something, I lived in Nairobi with my brother then someone from uni days hinted me about an interview and gave me a location, mimi huyo kesho asubuhi I'm on my corporate fit naenda interview. Kufika we are like 200 young hopeless....
3
3
4
1,217
Kenya needs to go back to the era where beer was 150, a litre of fuel at 150, a fielder 500K, probox at 400k, egg@10, motorbike @ 70k, 1 cigarrete 5 bob, cement @ 500 and 1 kilo of meat at 400. Who is running on this? Can the constitutionalism crowd guarantee us these basics?
92
338
37
1,423
33,687
…
So The 🌎 vs fuel corps Who are the big ones that show no mercy? Who’s trying to scrape the bottom of the barrel for every last drop ?🩸 How can we jointly push back?
1
1
15
Elly Maloba retweeted
Rain started beating us when we chose Public Private Partnerships (PPP) as a FINANCING OPTION instead of it remaining a PROCUREMENT OPTION. Mistake Number 1: We confirmed our POVERTY and said we don’t have money to develop our infrastructure and therefore we needed PARTNERS to help us raise funds. A bait for ABUSE. PPPs should NEVER be allowed where government cannot implement the project under Public Sector Comparator cost. Period! Opportunistic investors will take advantage of the taxpayer. Mistake Number 2: we confuse ‘Investment Decision’ for ‘Procurement Decision’. A project like Nairobi Expressway or my beloved RIRONI-MAU SUMMIT may pass the INVESTMENT DECISION, that is have more benefits that costs (CAPEX) from cost/benefit analysis, both social and economic - exogenous and endogenous - but, the same project may not pass the “PROCUREMENT DECISION”- to be procured under PPP. If you are not careful hapa kwa mistake number 2 ndio munaangukia mtihani! Hapa ndio munacheswa. Nobody is opposed to development projects. In fact, roads are the heartbeat of Millennial Development Goals, Africa Agenda 2063, Vision 2030, BETA Economic Agenda and Elections 2027. But if it doesn’t pass the procurement Decision, don’t force it down the throat of Kenyans as a PPP. It will be abused! For a Project to qualify to be procured as PPP it must demonstrate that it has a high VALUE FOR MONEY (VfM) - QUALITATIVE BENEFITS INCLUDED, than if it would have been procured traditionally. Sijui kama tunaelewana vizuri? Understand: whether it is User Pay or Government Pay if the Public Sector Comparator cost is less than PPP cost, that is a bad project. Wachana nayo. But, why should I bother? In any case a PPP project is good for accomplished engineers like myself and a few of my friends! PPP structure calls for very high administrative costs. As a distinguished contracts manager I will eat very well. It is our time to eat! Isn’t this bestial? ~disclaimer: I had to defend my friends for the sake of peace.
4
33
3
93
4,149
Elly Maloba retweeted
On UmojaExpress. Tell how a 27-kilometre highway moving over 245,000 vehicles daily can post quadrupling deficits despite booming top-line cash collections. The problem is accounting opacity. This is a textbook monopoly concession operating in a regulatory vacuum. Surely, routine road maintenance, lighting, and tollbooth operations on a 27-kilometre stretch cannot plausibly consume KSh 14.73 billion in a single year. Because Treasury disclosures lump "direct costs" into a single opaque figure without unbundling controllable operating expenditure from depreciation, amortization, and debt service, the public is flying blind. We cannot tell whether this KSh 5.1 billion deficit reflects genuine operational strain or aggressive front-loaded debt repayment and accounting depreciation structured to keep the project perpetually below revenue-sharing thresholds. Second is the original sin of infrastructure finance: currency mismatch. Kenya signed off on roughly $494 million in US Dollar-denominated financing for a road whose revenues are collected 100% in Kenya Shillings. By pegging base tariffs to the Dollar, the concession shifted foreign exchange risk onto Kenyan motorists. When the Shilling weakened toward KSh 160 to the Dollar in early 2024, tolls jumped by over 60%. Yet when the Shilling recovered and stabilized around KSh 129, tariffs never came down. Third, opacity breeds deep public skepticism around debt ownership. Persistent narratives suggest that portions of the project’s dollar-denominated debt instruments and subordinated notes are held by politically connected domestic interests, including businesses linked to the political elite. In project finance, senior and mezzanine lenders sit at the very top of the cash-flow waterfall, extracting steady dollar yields long before equity returns or state revenue-sharing triggers activate. When the Project Agreement, debt schedules, and beneficial ownership registries remain hidden from public audit—despite disclosure provisions in the PPP Act—a public asset becomes a private financial black box. If this framework remains untouched, the Nairobi Expressway will remain a "forever loss-making" concession on paper, giving its owners endless leverage to demand higher tolls and longer concession terms. - In mature jurisdictions, you have strict independent toll regulation. They enforce regulatory accounting ring-fencing that separates operating costs from financing charges and audits related-party contracts to stop inflated transfer pricing. They lodge open-book financial models with an independent regulator so tariff adjustments are symmetric and transparent. Kenya urgently needs a National Road Tolling Policy, an independent economic regulator, and full publication of Moja Expressway’s unbundled accounts and debt-holder register. Without transparency, motorists are not just paying for a road—they are underwriting an opaque balance sheet.
14
154
9
220
15,813
I wish I had revisited this speech earlier. I would have said things a lot more clearly. #CBCisheretostay
5
146
3
301
5,002
Elly Maloba retweeted
The US must be so desperate for actionable battlefield intel that they are willing to continue sacrificing prodigious numbers of $30M+ Reapers in vain attempts to penetrate Iranian airspace. The US military is woefully ill-prepared and ill-equipped to fight 21st century war.
About an hour ago, the IRGC Aerospace Force's newly developed air defense system engaged and hit the 58th MQ-9 drone belonging to the aggressor US military over the Strait of Hormuz.
37
286
4
1,472
30,278
Elly Maloba retweeted
Great cities are a product of high IQ, high trust society. That's why Tatu city rejects matatus and nduthi ngubus despite it housing over 100 factories and warehouses. Give Nairobi 500 B of annual budget and you will still fail to clean up Kirinyaga road
Planning and development wise, If major cities like Nairobi went to the dogs long ago, secondary and future corridor cities like Narok are slowly going to yo the hyenas.
2
1
38
"The best way to beat a technocrat hiding behind (accounting) jargon is to refuse to step into his rabbit hole and instead drag him back into plain, common-sense reality." #PeopleCentricConflictEarlyWarningEarlyResponse Gok bureaucracy technocrats edition
I have known and interacted with the head of the PPP Directorate, Eng Kepha Seda, for many years. He is a jolly good bloke—smart, with a deep sense of humour. In response to my tweet on the Umoja Expressway, he called me today to disagree with my views. He said I needed to catch up on accounting reporting for concessions, advising me to brush up on the difference between IFRIC 12 and IFRS 22 and to do some contemporary reading on "investment performance reporting." I have decided that the best way to beat a technocrat hiding behind accounting jargon is to refuse to step into his rabbit hole and instead drag him back into plain, common-sense reality. As a journalist, my job is to lay out clear, straightforward questions that any Kenyan motorist can grasp immediately. We do not need a masterclass in international accounting standards to spot a bad deal. Let’s stick to the plain common sense that every motorist on Mombasa Road understands: Four questions he must answer, 1.Why did we sign a deal requiring a road that collects 100% of its tolls in Kenya Shillings to be financed with 100% US Dollar debt? Did IFRIC 12 force the Treasury at gunpoint to approve an unhedged dollar liability? When the Shilling weakened to 160, tolls shot up by over 60% overnight. Yet when the Shilling strengthened back to 129, did IFRIC 12 mysteriously erase the "reverse" gear on the tolling machines? 2. how does sweeping the road, keeping the lights on, and manning tollbooths on a brand-new 27-kilometre stretch cost a whopping KSh 14.73 billion in a single year—more than the annual budgets of several Kenyan counties? Are they paving the road with gold leaf every Tuesday? 3. Over 245,000 cars pay every single day, bringing in KSh 9.63 billion, yet the operator is "crying in losses." Who are the mysterious dollar bondholders sitting at the front of the queue, drinking all the milk while telling Kenyans the cow is starving? 4. Why does the Electronic Toll Collection (ETC) system lock out a motorist who still has KSh 350 of their own cash sitting in the account? Is that also an "IFRIC 12 investment performance" requirement? We cannot allow the Umoja Expressway to continue hiding behind accounting textbooks. Let them publish the actual cash operating costs, the interest rates, and the list of debt holders. Motorists can tell the difference between an accounting loss on paper and a cash machine operating in broad daylight. My parting shot: When a doctor can't explain why the patient is bleeding, he starts speaking Latin. When the PPP Directorate can't explain why a KSh 9.6 billion cash-cow road is "losing" KSh 5.1 billion, they start shouting "IFRIC 12! Tell it to the birds.
18
Elly Maloba retweeted
Replying to @jaindikisero
The information you have and the gaps identified in the lingering questions makes the inquiry ripe for a Request for Information to the National Treasury under Article 35 of the constitution and Access to Information Act 2016. It may be the next best step.
4
1,254
Elly Maloba retweeted
Replying to @jaindikisero
They are masking payouts to interested cartels under normal operating expenses like watering flowers, sweeping, etc maintenance and other complex accounting /IFRS jargon. We need @OAG_Kenya to review their books.
1
2
2
604
Elly Maloba retweeted
Replying to @jaindikisero
Very fundamental questions demanding immediate response. I've never understood why you need a minimum of 490/- to use the expressway even when you join from one or two points away from its last point. @NrbXpressway_Ke
1
6
1,890
Elly Maloba retweeted
Replying to @jaindikisero
Because it is a PPP and if you make a loss, then in the next budget the govt votes to send you taxpayers billions to keep you afloat.....same for KQ, same for SGR....a well thought through looting scheme..... making a loss is the most profitable strategy for a cash rich public business..... You might also see proposals to sell it like the pipeline, very soon.....
2
6
23
2,812
Elly Maloba retweeted
Replying to @jaindikisero
Those Accounting Standards should not replace common sense. Kenya is bleeding. We are becoming poorer. I wonder if the likes of Seda can start a Kiosk and apply IFRS22. They only do it on Public Funds.
3
14
71
5,583
Elly Maloba retweeted
I have known and interacted with the head of the PPP Directorate, Eng Kepha Seda, for many years. He is a jolly good bloke—smart, with a deep sense of humour. In response to my tweet on the Umoja Expressway, he called me today to disagree with my views. He said I needed to catch up on accounting reporting for concessions, advising me to brush up on the difference between IFRIC 12 and IFRS 22 and to do some contemporary reading on "investment performance reporting." I have decided that the best way to beat a technocrat hiding behind accounting jargon is to refuse to step into his rabbit hole and instead drag him back into plain, common-sense reality. As a journalist, my job is to lay out clear, straightforward questions that any Kenyan motorist can grasp immediately. We do not need a masterclass in international accounting standards to spot a bad deal. Let’s stick to the plain common sense that every motorist on Mombasa Road understands: Four questions he must answer, 1.Why did we sign a deal requiring a road that collects 100% of its tolls in Kenya Shillings to be financed with 100% US Dollar debt? Did IFRIC 12 force the Treasury at gunpoint to approve an unhedged dollar liability? When the Shilling weakened to 160, tolls shot up by over 60% overnight. Yet when the Shilling strengthened back to 129, did IFRIC 12 mysteriously erase the "reverse" gear on the tolling machines? 2. how does sweeping the road, keeping the lights on, and manning tollbooths on a brand-new 27-kilometre stretch cost a whopping KSh 14.73 billion in a single year—more than the annual budgets of several Kenyan counties? Are they paving the road with gold leaf every Tuesday? 3. Over 245,000 cars pay every single day, bringing in KSh 9.63 billion, yet the operator is "crying in losses." Who are the mysterious dollar bondholders sitting at the front of the queue, drinking all the milk while telling Kenyans the cow is starving? 4. Why does the Electronic Toll Collection (ETC) system lock out a motorist who still has KSh 350 of their own cash sitting in the account? Is that also an "IFRIC 12 investment performance" requirement? We cannot allow the Umoja Expressway to continue hiding behind accounting textbooks. Let them publish the actual cash operating costs, the interest rates, and the list of debt holders. Motorists can tell the difference between an accounting loss on paper and a cash machine operating in broad daylight. My parting shot: When a doctor can't explain why the patient is bleeding, he starts speaking Latin. When the PPP Directorate can't explain why a KSh 9.6 billion cash-cow road is "losing" KSh 5.1 billion, they start shouting "IFRIC 12! Tell it to the birds.
122
693
50
1,121
93,554
Planning and development wise, If major cities like Nairobi went to the dogs long ago, secondary and future corridor cities like Narok are slowly going to yo the hyenas.
3
4
18
872
Replying to @Alfayaz11
Oh My I had similar experience with a friend from UK never been to Msa. Mombasa and Tuktuks and also Kwale gave him a migraine and he asked me do you guys go through this on daily basis. The imaginary break on his side was torturous . We can still have Tuktuks and Boda Bodas but orderly. We are allergic to orderly life. I recall going to Kigali with friends from Kenya and they told me "Bwana this place is too ordely , we miss commotion bana"
2
3
27
1,961
Elly Maloba retweeted
This week, I have been hosting the new Africa Aftermarket Sales Manager of a German OE manufacturing company that has been supplying us for over three decades. It is his first visit to Kenya, and he is here in Nairobi for the week. Like most first-time visitors, he was excited and curious. On his first day, he was very impressed with Nairobi and even told the hotel staff how modern and clean the city looked. Little did he know that his entire experience of Nairobi at that point was the journey from JKIA to his hotel using the Expressway. He naturally got chatting with the hotel staff and waiters, asking about life in Kenya and Nairobi. He learnt quite a bit about the challenges people face daily. The following day, as we were heading to visit customers in Industrial Area, he asked if we could avoid the Expressway and use the normal roads, including Uhuru Highway, so he could get a proper feel of the city. Well, the past few days have been quite an experience, and frankly, a nightmare for me. What he has witnessed has left him completely shocked. The garbage, the stench, poor roads, open drainages, disorder, the madness of matatus and boda bodas, pedestrians crossing anywhere, even animals on the roads, and the general lack of order. Throughout our journeys around Nairobi, the poor man has practically had his foot on an imaginary brake! Keeps shouting watch out 😂😂😂. He did not realise how Bodas come out like swarms of bees in every direction. He keeps asking questions and comparing what he had heard and seen in pictures with what he is now witnessing firsthand. One question really stood out, “Is this what you people have to go through every single day?” How?? He genuinely cannot understand how people have come to accept such conditions as normal, especially when Nairobi is often described as one of Africa’s best capital cities. Personally for me it has been embarrassing. This is my home, my city and my country, and naturally, I would want any visitor to leave with a good impression. Unfortunately, the reality on the ground tells a very different story. The sad part is that we have become so accustomed to filth, disorder, chaos and poor infrastructure that some people no longer see anything wrong with it. Those who have made peace with mediocrity will quickly tell you that Nairobi is doing much better than other cities. Show them what is happening in Addis Ababa or Kigali, and they will probably tell you the pictures are AI. Others will ask why you don’t go back to your country, and of course, some members of the 527/- praise and worship gang will have the audacity to come out with their usual “Ni njaa ama wivu inakusumbua?” We have reached a point where demanding basic services, proper infrastructure, cleanliness, safety and law and order is treated as asking for too much. We keep lowering the bar, normalising the unacceptable and celebrating mediocrity, theatrics and clownery instead of demanding competence, accountability and results. As I always say, we are not short of potential, we are short of serious leadership and the willingness to demand better. It is what it is. #ReclaimNairobi
74
131
21
358
27,907
"Sadly, accustomed to filth, disorder, chaos and poor infrastructure that some people no longer see anything wrong with it. The garbage, the stench and the general lack of order is not short of potential, but lack of serious leadership and the willingness to demand better."
This week, I have been hosting the new Africa Aftermarket Sales Manager of a German OE manufacturing company that has been supplying us for over three decades. It is his first visit to Kenya, and he is here in Nairobi for the week. Like most first-time visitors, he was excited and curious. On his first day, he was very impressed with Nairobi and even told the hotel staff how modern and clean the city looked. Little did he know that his entire experience of Nairobi at that point was the journey from JKIA to his hotel using the Expressway. He naturally got chatting with the hotel staff and waiters, asking about life in Kenya and Nairobi. He learnt quite a bit about the challenges people face daily. The following day, as we were heading to visit customers in Industrial Area, he asked if we could avoid the Expressway and use the normal roads, including Uhuru Highway, so he could get a proper feel of the city. Well, the past few days have been quite an experience, and frankly, a nightmare for me. What he has witnessed has left him completely shocked. The garbage, the stench, poor roads, open drainages, disorder, the madness of matatus and boda bodas, pedestrians crossing anywhere, even animals on the roads, and the general lack of order. Throughout our journeys around Nairobi, the poor man has practically had his foot on an imaginary brake! Keeps shouting watch out 😂😂😂. He did not realise how Bodas come out like swarms of bees in every direction. He keeps asking questions and comparing what he had heard and seen in pictures with what he is now witnessing firsthand. One question really stood out, “Is this what you people have to go through every single day?” How?? He genuinely cannot understand how people have come to accept such conditions as normal, especially when Nairobi is often described as one of Africa’s best capital cities. Personally for me it has been embarrassing. This is my home, my city and my country, and naturally, I would want any visitor to leave with a good impression. Unfortunately, the reality on the ground tells a very different story. The sad part is that we have become so accustomed to filth, disorder, chaos and poor infrastructure that some people no longer see anything wrong with it. Those who have made peace with mediocrity will quickly tell you that Nairobi is doing much better than other cities. Show them what is happening in Addis Ababa or Kigali, and they will probably tell you the pictures are AI. Others will ask why you don’t go back to your country, and of course, some members of the 527/- praise and worship gang will have the audacity to come out with their usual “Ni njaa ama wivu inakusumbua?” We have reached a point where demanding basic services, proper infrastructure, cleanliness, safety and law and order is treated as asking for too much. We keep lowering the bar, normalising the unacceptable and celebrating mediocrity, theatrics and clownery instead of demanding competence, accountability and results. As I always say, we are not short of potential, we are short of serious leadership and the willingness to demand better. It is what it is. #ReclaimNairobi
1
95