Sasha retweeted
I covered Myanmar's slaughter of the Rohingya, and talked to the mother of a baby thrown onto a bonfire, to a girl locked in a hut that was set on fire. So it is heartening to see the Int'l Court of Justice rule that this was genocide. Shout-out to Gambia for bringing the case.
So far I was in the fence whether the ICJ will find Israel liable of genocide. My intitial take of the Myanmar decision is that this will move my expectation to slightly above 50%.
Main reasons FOR that:
- court found the “targeted population” to be all Rohingya in Rakhine, not just those killed directly; applied to Gaza this removes any doubt re “substantiality”
- the court clarified that not the number of deaths alone is relevant to infer genocidal intent (the the deaths in Gaza are of anything higher)
- “they killed less people than they could have” does not disprove genocidal intent
- other aims may exist alongside genocidal intent, so neither war nor counterterrorism rule out the existence of genocide per se
- “only reasonable inference” has to be looked at holistically, ie all acts taken together; if these are (only) consistent with genocidal intent then that is conclusively established
- In terms of evidence, the court fully relied on the UN’s fact finding missions reports
HOWEVER the court also made decision that still make me hesitant to move much beyond 50%:
- the ruling was only adopted by 9-6 votes; it would only take two to switch to reverse the ruling (although the composition of the court will change)
- the court stuck to “only reasonable inference”, and even clarified this means the *sole* reasonable inference — even if that is to be based on the totality of the evidence; if that still allows for “brutal counterterrorism” as alternative explanation, then there cannot be a genocide finding
- the court rejected the claim that Myanmar violated the “inflicting conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction” act, despite rather horrific conditions Rohingya have been subjected to; in Gaza a low threshold for this act would likely have been met, but given the rejection here it might not be
- proving intentional killing will likely be more difficult in Gaza than in Myanmar, where many such acts were rather obvious given widespread TMD massacres; in Gaza the IDF will argue most civilian deaths were not intentional but rather incidental, and it’s not clear the court will accept the aid site shootings and other atrocities as sufficiently widespread and systematic as to prove genocidal intent
Any other thoughts or links to takes welcome!
If you want a bit by bit summary of how the ICJ arrived at its conclusion that Myanmar committed genocide this thread, short of reading the actual ruling, is a great resource:
Probably the shortest possible comprehensive summary of the judgment. If you don’t want to read anything else, at least read this to understand what and why the court ruled:
The International Court of Justice for the first time finds a state guilty of genocide. Court conclusively finds Myanmar security forces had the intent to destroy in whole, or in part, the Rohingya population in Northern Rakhine State in its 2017 clearance operations. In addition state manifestly failed to meet its duties to prevent a genocide.
Court finds Myanmar security forces engaged in indiscriminate large scale killings, sexual violence and deliberate burning of Rohingya villages including attacking Rohingya as they fled to Bangladesh. As many as 10,000 killed in clearance operations.
State should also have been aware that presence of non state actors in attacks on Rohingya and manifestly failed to take all the measures that were within its powers to prevent a genocide. Myanmar knew or should have known of a serious risk of genocide
For genocide to be established under Genocide Convention the intent to destroy a group in whole or part is the element that distinguishes the crime from other war crimes, including breaches of international humanitarian law or even ethnic cleansing.
Intent can be established through direct and indirect circumstantial evidence, but stresses its jurisprudence requires genocidal intent must be the only reasonable inference that can be drawn from the evidence.
ICJ case says genocidal intent can co-exist with other additional intents, including in this case a counter-insurgency operation. But ICJ found nature of counter insurgency operation including mass burning of villages and child killings was consistent with genocidal intent.
Found no evidence either the intent to deport, or to punish the population was an alternative explanation. Scale nature and methods went well beyond what is required to punish a population, and so does not constitute a reasonable alternative explanation.
To examine intent Court said it looked at general context, including legislative discrimination; the selective targeting of Rohingya; acts that violate the foundations of the group, including sexual violence and child deaths; and the systematic nature of targeting, including the burning of 392 villages and killing of 10,000.
Destruction of a group can mean more than deaths, or biological destruction. Part of Rohingya population targeted was substantial, even if military did not take every opportunity to kill. ICJ estimates only 1.2% of population were killed.
Court highlights the forcible deportation of children as indicative of genocidal intent. Adds serious bodily injures were intentionally inflicted including acts of rape contributing serious mental harm. Court found most that survived forcible displacement have had little chance to return due to the bulldozing of their homes, leading to serious mental harm to a significant number of the protected group.
Restrictions on Rohingya access to citizenship and freedom of movement was not so great as being objectively capable causing death over time.
But restrictions on the group's birth rate was a coercive measure intended to reduce births within the group. Magnitude of sexual violence in 2017 clearance operations was intended to reduce population's willingness to procreate, and led to social stigma.
Myanmar state had an obligation to prevent its security forces from committing genocide.
Rohingya qualify as a distinct group, predominantly Muslim with a unique culture and self identify as an ethnic group.
ICJ said the burden of proof had fallen on the accuser The Gambia to prove its case. Fear of reprisal did not impugn credibility of Gambia witnesses, and court found witness evidence given to court, sometimes in private, was consistent with other reliable evidence.
2
110
Sasha retweeted
Court finds that the only reasonable inference is an intent to destroy a substantial part of the Rohingya group.
Court is fully convinced that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya.
Historic.
27/
It’s not even really my position, but this argument is going to work like kryptonite among Americans, esp liberal ones.
Because *unlike European nation states*, the US is, by design, a universalist state and this is drilled down into pupils from the get go.
And Americans obviously also have the tendency to see the rest of the world mostly through their own eyes, and the US as the ultimate normative benchmark.
So the “of course they should be as universalist as we are” argument, once eloquently made, is going to be home run with a large number of Americans, and arguing against it a pretty steep uphill battle.
Abdul El-Sayed on what Israel should be:
I believe that Israel ought to be a country that upholds equal rights for all of its citizens, does not identify itself with a culture or a faith, and that dignifies the rights of those citizens to live free under its laws.
That's, again, the question of peace, dignity, and self-determination.
The Iran war largely turned into a shadow war, but is far from over.
The US blockade works, and the US + UAE have also been quite successful in getting oil out of the Gulf — but at a seemingly pretty high price. This isn’t really sustainable forever, even less so if Congress turns the screws on financing the war.
So how to get out of it, without a deal that doesn’t really look better than anything discussed before the war (and quite possibly worse!) remains remains a riddle.
Thomas Friedman on the effectiveness of Iran's missiles
“I had a briefing from a senior Emirati oil official who shared with me a digital map of the relentless Iranian attacks on the fleet of Emirati-owned oil tankers....
"These are highly sophisticated attacks, mostly with cruise missiles and drones, that go right into the oil tankers’ engine rooms and disable them. Bull’s-eye every time. The Emirates then has to send tugboats out to rescue the crews and pull the disabled tankers into port. This is happening almost every day.”
nytimes.com/2026/11/17/opini…
1
105
Sasha retweeted
Replying to @AniYehodi
The honest answer is: the IDF hasn’t found a way to “win this war”, and there also might not be a realistic one.
What the IDF *actually did* in the war was wholly insufficient to actually destroy and dismantle Hamas, it came not even close. And there’s zero indication the IDF has any other strategies beyond those it employed in the last three years. In fact what it is doing *right in this minute* resembles exactly what it did countless times before, which did not do anything to actually dislodge Hamas. (Read the Fox article)
That’s a fair summary of what the ICJ ruling re Myanmar is most likely to look like.
Basically the court will probably clarify that “the only reasonable inference” test means that genocidal intent is the necessary conclusion of a pattern of actions, and not that it’s the sole explanation or motivation for every single act.
If that’s the outcome (which most lawyers would probably find rather reasonable) it will be interesting to see whether the US (and other actors) nonetheless continue with their attempts to discredit the court. If the case then moves on to the UNSC it will also be interesting whether China, Russia or even the US block the imposition of any consequences.
Prediction for tomorrow’s decision in the ICJ’s Gambia v. Myanmar case tomorrow:
1.) It is likely that Myanmar will be found culpable for the commission of the crime of genocide, or at the very least not preventing genocide.
2.) There’s a lot of discussion on the intent standard and what the ICJ will do. That discussion has been centered on “lowering” the standard. I don’t think that they will. I think that the Court will likely clarify that the “only reasonable inference” test will not preclude a finding of genocide in military conflict. Meaning that they will state that an accusation of genocide can be sustained where a state has a stated military objective BUT that can coexist with genocidal intent IF the only reasonable inference on the totality of the evidence points to genocidal intent.
This isn’t an unreasonable clarification in the law. However, it’s important to note that military conflict itself is not prima facie evidence of genocidal intent. Which many have seemed to try to expand towards.
Finding that genocidal intent can coexist with a military objective also does not “condemn” Israel in the later contentious proceedings. This was a clarification that the Netherlands, British, Belgians, etc. had argued in their interventions for interpretation and that was largely pre-Oct. 7.
This “change” would not necessarily do much other than issue a clarification while also not gutting the only reasonable inference test. It would still apply to the circumstantial evidence test (and it’s not necessarily unique to genocide cases).
We have to remember that the ICJ as an institution is bound by treaty and deeply cares about its reputation and legitimacy. Completely rewriting the law outside the bounds of the Convention is a non-starter and would create a legitimacy crisis for not just the ICJ, but also the UN. They will want to avoid that.
If they do as I suspect they will as stated above, that’s a clarification I would defend.
3.) The biggest question (in my mind) that needs to be addressed is that watching the oral arguments of both the Gambia and Myanmar, I expected more from the proponents (Gambia) in their oral arguments to prove their case to the fully conclusive standard. I was unconvinced by their arguments and gave an interview as they were starting to stating that I expected them to have enough to fully conclusively prove their case. This is important because the burden of persuasion is on them, not Myanmar. I was shocked at their arguments (even at one point them arguing that the legal test is *a* reasonable inference and not *only* [they later corrected this]).
The standard of proof here is extremely high and difficult to reach. I’m curious how the ICJ reasons their way to a conclusion one way or the other.
4.) This is not a prediction but just a point about what the Rohingya went through and a determination either way will not bring back those who were killed and it will not undo what happened there.
I could very well be wrong about what they’re going to do, and I know there’s been a lot of fear and posturing saying that they’ll be changing everything just so they can “convict” Israel in the future, but the evidence hasn’t actually suggested that and I think it would be a bridge too far that they won’t take.
Anyways, bookmark this to tell me I’m wrong if I land up being wrong.
1
17
944
Least surprising leak revelations ever, probably.
NEW INVESTIGATION: Inside decades of dysfunction at Deutsche Bank. This year alone the bank has been raided three times by the German authorities.
Now millions of leaked documents reveal internal chaos, flawed processes and organisational ineptitude ft.trib.al/P39aLZu
1
4
100
Sasha retweeted
Periodic reminder that Germany nailed it when they argued that the EU AML authority should be in Frankfurt so that inspectors could just walk to DB
NEW INVESTIGATION: Inside decades of dysfunction at Deutsche Bank. This year alone the bank has been raided three times by the German authorities.
Now millions of leaked documents reveal internal chaos, flawed processes and organisational ineptitude ft.trib.al/P39aLZu
Sasha retweeted
I’ll be in the court Thurs for the ICJ’s judgment in The Gambia v. Myanmar, the historic Rohingya genocide case. Many have asked what happens if the ICJ finds Myanmar responsible for genocide & the junta defies the ruling. There are several possible paths forward. A thread:
Sasha retweeted
I was interviewed by @EstherSolomon for @haaretzcom on why the @CIJ_ICJ ruling this Thursday on the genocide
claim in Myanmar should be watched closely in Jerusalem
‘Israel should be pretty worried’: The ICJ decides this week whether killings, mass displacement & incitement constitute genocide – in Myanmar. Their decision will have a fateful impact on the case accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza | Analysis @haaretzcom
haaretz.com/world-news/2026-…
Sasha retweeted
Replying to @KseniaSvetlova
Will be interesting to see how the Israeli banks actually handle the UK sanctions, as in the case of the 2024 US sanctions they initially complied with them, and froze the designated settlers accounts, but then reversed this after pressure from Smotrich and assurances from the US.
Now, such assurances will likely not come from the UK, but they will sure face domestic pressure NOT to implement these sanctions themselves.
However not doing so could just end up with them getting sanctioned as well — which would pretty much cut them off from most global financial institutions.
Replying to @SimonWaldman1 @SaraHirschhorn1
The operational impact will likely be limited, unless the Israeli banks also implement the sanctions (which they initially did in the case of the US settler sanctions in 2024, but then reversed their stance after pressure from Smotrich and US Treasury “clarified” it wouldn’t expect the Israeli banks to follow them [bit of a weird move]).
If however the banks themselves end up as designated entities in the UK that would be a pretty big deal, as that would effectively shut them out from almost any other global financial institution.
Good. Hope they’re also having tough talks with the banks though to make clear they have limited time to stop and wind down their business in the settlements, or they’re going on the list as well.




































