Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
A Wharton economist ran a randomized controlled trial on almost a thousand high school students in Turkey.
The result was so brutal for the AI-in-education narrative that it had to be peer-reviewed by PNAS before people would believe it.
Her name is Hamsa Bastani. She teaches operations and information at the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania, and the study she published in 2025 alongside her co-authors is one of the cleanest experiments anyone has run on what AI actually does to learning when you remove it from the equation and check what is left.
The setup was a randomized controlled trial, the same methodology used in clinical drug trials. Nearly a thousand high school math students in Turkey were split into three groups and put through four sessions of ninety minutes each. One group practiced with GPT Base, a standard ChatGPT-4 interface that could answer any question directly. One group practiced with GPT Tutor, a version of the same model that had been prompted to guide students with hints rather than hand them the answer. One group practiced with nothing but their textbook and their own head.
During the practice sessions, the AI groups looked like a miracle. The GPT Base group solved 48% more problems than the students working alone. The GPT Tutor group solved 127% more. Every administrator looking at those numbers would have written a press release about the transformative power of AI in education and moved on.
Then the actual exam came, and AI was not allowed.
The students who had practiced with GPT Base scored 17% worse than the students who had practiced alone. Seventeen percent worse, despite having solved nearly half again as many problems in the sessions leading up to it. The students who had struggled the most, who had sat with the confusion and worked through it without a tool to rescue them, were now the only ones who could actually do the math when it counted.
Bastani's team read through the chat logs to understand what had actually been happening during the practice sessions, and the answer was exactly what the exam results had already implied. The GPT Base group had not been learning. They had been extracting answers and moving on, and every moment that felt like understanding was actually the model doing the cognitive work while the student's brain waited for the next problem to arrive. The paper describes it precisely: without guardrails, students attempt to use GPT-4 as a crutch during practice, and subsequently perform worse on their own.
The detail that should follow every conversation about AI in education is the one buried in the post-test survey results. The students who had relied on AI the most during practice were also the most confident they had understood the material. The tool had not just failed to teach them. It had convinced them they had learned something they had not, which is a different kind of failure entirely and a much harder one to correct because the student has no idea it is happening.
The crutch had made them confident and weak at the same time.
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
The consequences of the concession that @IndiGo6E has obtained
1) para 3.11 Night Duty which is 12 mid night to 6am has reverted back to until 5am
2) Para 6.1.4 ( for operations encroaching Night Duty the limit is 2 landings. This 2 landing limit has been removed:
Result for IndiGo It can schedule crew for more than 2 consecutive nights and for more than 2 landings:
Result for Pilots : increased fatigue , increased stress increased Duty hours Minimum Rest:
These concession have by and large negated the Fatigue Management intent of the FDTL phase 2 effective 1st November 2025.
@MoCA_GoI there was No APPLICATION OF MIND by you on the effects in fatigue when giving theses concession which @DGCAIndia will have to extend to other Airlines too.
Well played
@DelhiHighCourt
Well Well Well:
As expected @airindia has also demanded the same concession as given to @IndiGo6E : How can @DGCAIndia refuse. Slowly the FDTL CAR WILL HAVE MORE CONCESSIONS then compliance: well played IndiGo @MoCA_GoI
Can a citizen donate to Electoral Bonds instead of paying Income tax. This will stop citizen harassment and maf karo minor breaches of law.
@FinMinIndia please consider for next budget
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
पावसाळा काही दिवसांवर येऊन ठेपला आहे. पावसाळ्यात गड किल्ले, वनक्षेत्र, धबधबे या ठिकाणी उपद्रवी, हुल्लडबाज पर्यटकांची होणारी गर्दी आणि अपघात रोखण्यासाठी @mataonline च्या संवाद पुरवणीतील @chaitralicMT यांच्या लेखातील मतांचा आदर प्रशासनाने करत, कठोर उपाययोजना कराव्यात. @MahaForest
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
Breaking News: Andrew 'Sandy' Irvine's remains possibly uncovered on Everest. A century after the climber disappeared alongside George Mallory, a National Geographic team has made a discovery that may shed light on one of the greatest adventure mysteries in history. More: buff.ly/4eCB0sU
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
आपण निसर्गाचा दरारा मान्य करायला हवा.
👉🏼या एपिसोड मध्ये अनेक महत्त्वाच्या गोष्टी सांगितल्या आहेत.
👉🏼यात दिलेली इन्शुरन्स ची माहिती तर सगळ्यात महत्त्वाची.
🙏🏼आपल्याशी बोलताहेत पुष्कराज आपटे. हे ट्रेकर, प्रशिक्षक आहेत.. शिवाय महाराष्ट्र ऍडव्हेंचर कौन्सिलचे संचालक ही आहेत.
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
On this day, 27.07.2023, 🇳🇴 Kristin Harila and 🇳🇵 Tenjen Lama redefined the limits of human endurance, completing all 14 eight-thousanders in just 92 days, breaking Nirmal Purja's record of 189 days!🙏
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
xitter.gq/i/spaces/1lPJqOE…
- Stories of war make us aware of the brave acts of our heroes. These stories make us realise how “grateful “we should be to those who displayed courage and determination. Stories of war not told are forgotten. For the sake of our country and for the sake of next generation we must continue to discuss these acts of courage and leadership.
- This 26 July , it will be 25 years since the Kargil War.
- A generation born after 1999 ( 25 years now ) may not be fully aware of “how , what ,why “ of Op Safed Sagar. Those born 1990-1999 were too young then to have any memory of the happenings.
- Join me on a space understand “ Kargil War : Op Safed Sagar “ on 18 July 2000-2130 hrs.
- I assure you will get many insights into leadership , courage , selfless service.
#gratitude
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
If you catch a taxi or a rickshaw from Pune AirPort Terminal “new”
You pay 300 ₹ toll.
Wah @mohol_murlidhar ji Wah
This is what Chaiwalla has gifted Punekars. @BJP4India @BJP4PuneFreeBus
Not to be outdone,
All the rick guys now pick up your baggage and see you post the toll gate manned by none other than our homegrown BVG chaps - a housekeeping company which has now transmogrified into a toll Collection company.
The public transportation or that “bus” due to do the loop route from Ramwadi Metro to the Airport Gate is
Missing as usual. Why can’t a bus lie in wait until 2 others keep at it on the route is as of yet unexplained. Passengers will wait patiently if they’re assured transportation every ten minutes to and fro a place where pesky tolls and traffic can be obviated. @PMPMLPune & @CredaiPunemetro @punemetrorider need to figure this last mile business out, else there’s no choice but to go through what one always did, new terminal - any terminal notwithstanding.,
A little walking never did any damage, so Punekars are often observed walking out while others are "sitting ducks" so to speak.
This blatant profligacy with tax payer money, is what Pune signed up for @AjitPawarSpeaks @Dev_Fadnavis @mieknathshinde ?
The new airport may never come and even if it does arrive - that "purandar or rajgurunagar" option or the Navi Mumbai one might as well be considered equidistant or the same, time vs distance = opportunity cost of flying.
meanwhile with all of @nitin_gadkari 's projects in "rain" shambles one way or another - that 2 hour dream we got sold
has come a cropper., including "jalebi" oops chandni chowk..
GDP loss due to climate events are our new reality, whither growth when you cant manage 100 + mm of rain.
is Pune ok with paying 300 ₹ toll at the airport cos you want to enter a city. @Uber_India @Olacabs (cab fare extra).
Is it fair to make people do so when the truth is that nothings been delivered. a new airport never came, tolls however have emerged.
Pune sees over 200 flight movements and over 40,000 passenger footfalls daily, even minus this new building. Now we pay through our noses to access our own city.
This when we have a minister we are supposed to own. The jokes on us "Pune" as usual.
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
𝐋.𝐄.𝐆.𝐄.𝐍.𝐃
#TDF2024
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
🥲 THE DREAM COMES TRUE
#TDF2024
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
As said, summitting #Kangchenjunga was not impossible; only the ropes were not fixed. Luckily, Bartek and Oswald didn't need them. Congratulations to the Polish climbers, looking forward to reading the details when they return.
explorersweb.com/two-surpris…
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
Ten years ago today, just one of the many drives, actively keeping #VetalTekdi clean @sushmadate @AmeyaJagtap_ @pushkarajapte @sumitakale @PMCPune and so many more!
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
#pune mandali
- Pune Aviation Gallery is a 4 storey museum which has some amazing information about Aviation.
- There are museums relating to aviation which are run by Indian Navy and Indian Air Force. This is the only one which is non fauji in that sense.
- It’s a collaborative effort between PMC and Mahalaxmi Learning Foundation.
- It’s a superbly planned and executed museum which will create favourable learning environment for all Aviaiton enthusiasts.
- We invite all Punekars to visit the museum and help us make it better.
- In coming months that Gallery will also become a knowledge hub for all aspects related to aviation.
- Today, we had a single group of around 120 visitors. In coming months we are hopeful that all Punekars enjoy this experience.
- Schools , colleges , associations all can plan their visit by contacting the given number.
- maps.app.goo.gl/cRdty7kTFfio…
#aviation #pune
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
"It was like a meteor that he passed across the Indian sky and cut in his wake the body of Hindustani Music in two neat halves,one before Kumar Gandharva one after him, a kind of BC and AD in Indian music" - Raghava Menon
Kumarji is 100 today. Not possible to speak in past tense.
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
Today is a very special day. Kumar Gandharva's 100th Birthday. Happy Birthday Kumarji. Thank you for enriching my life with all the wonderful music. 🙏 #KumarjiCentenary #KumarGandharva
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
Tagging Punekars here who may like to attend this in case they don't know about it already. The opportunity to hear Baba Adhav amongst others speak.. @Makarand_S @netshrink @pushkarajapte
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
No solid evidence, just questions and spy-like stories, but nevertheless an ever-interesting topic 🍿. Plus, some testimonies come from people I have followed for years and respect.
explorersweb.com/did-the-chi…
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
New credit card scam. Someone calls from ICICI Bank, says there's an "Card Protection" charge (₹2500) on your card, & you can cancel it. You say yes. They send an elaborate ICICI clone website. This is the link for reference. DO NOT OPEN IT. CALL THE BANK dev-icicicardhelp.pantheonsi…
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
Discovering historical temples in #Pune has been the utmost satisfying and challenging Treasure Hunt for me. After so long was able to locate (atleast) 250 year old temple at Ganj Peth. The Peshwa records had referred to it as Ram temple at the Bhagwandas Bairagi Math.(मठ) (1/2)
Pushkaraj Apte retweeted
A very cordial invitation to #Dombivli music lovers. Do join us in celebrating Pt Gajananbuwa Joshi Ji’s Smrutidin on Jan 14th, 2024 at 6 pm #icm #khayal #hindustani #music







































