Tomos Roberts-Young retweeted
The recent Welsh Labour report into why they lost in Senedd election says they need to differentiate themselves from UK Labour.
Yet I haven't see any current Labour Senedd Member say one word of opposition at their own PM dismissing longstanding Welsh Labour policies.
I swear somebody has to tell Jason O’Connell about Scotland one day - would be incredible.
Here’s 5, enjoy!
1. Policing works better when it’s joined up across the border. Welsh forces already rely on the bigger England-and-Wales system for specialist teams, intelligence, and cross-border work. Carving Wales out just to please Plaid creates new barriers and weakens the very thing that keeps people safe. That’s not devolution, it’s fragmentation for the sake of it.
2. The justice system is the same story. Wales already gets the scale and expertise of the shared system while still having its own forums and input. Plaid’s answer is always “give us more powers,” but they never explain how that actually reduces reoffending or helps victims better than the partnership we already have.
3. On the Crown Estate, the current setup is what actually delivers investment. The scale and financial muscle matter when you’re trying to land floating offshore wind and the jobs that come with it. Plaid want control for political reasons, not because it would produce better outcomes for Welsh ports or supply chains. We should be maximising the Celtic Sea opportunity, not starting another constitutional row.
4. Rail is highly integrated across the border. Handing full infrastructure control to Cardiff would split a network that passengers actually use every day. Great British Railways working with Transport for Wales is the practical way to get investment and improvements. Plaid’s demand is pure symbolism that risks making services worse.
5. Plaid treat every issue as a demand for more power in Cardiff. Most people want decisions made closer to them in their towns and regions, not just a bigger budget and more ministers in the Senedd. Real reform is about driving power down to places and communities, not endlessly transferring it from one parliament to another while services stay broken.
67
Almost as if Plaid Members and members can hold two thoughts in their minds at the same time.
All the Plaid mouthpieces are out in force slating Andy Burnham tonight after spending all day slapping him on the back for edging us closer to the EU.
You couldn’t make it up. They’re screaming at him for refusing to devolve more powers to Wales while egging him on to rejoin the EU and hand power over Welsh farming policy back to unelected bureaucrats in Brussels.
So much for putting Wales first.
Vote Plaid. Get Clowns 🤡
1
11
371
Tomos Roberts-Young retweeted
Andy Burnham has rejected more devolution for Wales while championing it in England.
Wales is just asking for what Scotland already has.
The UK Government isn't just treating Wales as less of a country than Scotland.
It's treating Wales as less deserving than a region of England.
Tomos Roberts-Young retweeted
The Prime Minister has said no to Wales.
No to the Crown Estate. No to policing and justice. No to our railways.
Labour talks about devolution, but refuses to treat Wales as an equal nation.
Plaid Cymru will always stand up for Wales.
🏴
Tomos Roberts-Young retweeted
This is the latest projected map for Wales from the authoritative @DevolvedVotes - with Labour destined for third place in votes, the fight between Reform and Plaid - if current trends hold will be very tight indeed!
Tomos Roberts-Young retweeted
The sheer hypocrisy: thin gruel for Wales while full fat powers for English mayors.
Just like his Labour and Tory predecessors, Burnham is happy to deny Wales powers long devolved to the other nations,
Labour learned nothing from its hammering in May. bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ck98…
lol
Today in the Senedd during the draft budget debate, the impact of business rates on local businesses was raised.
Plaid Cymru again pointed to the so-called cut. It is not a cut. It is permanent targeted relief from April 2027 for a defined subset of leisure, tourism, hospitality and retail properties with a rateable value under £51,000, funded by a small rise in the higher multiplier on the largest properties.
Overall non-domestic rates yield is broadly unchanged.
Everyone else still faces the full effect of revaluation, inflation and rising costs.
It puts more pressure on the businesses left out. It offers no answer to structural headwinds - rising costs, Bank of England interest rates that raise borrowing costs for firms and for councils already in debt, or the wider anti-business measures from UK Labour. Higher tax and job-killing legislation remain untouched.
The Draft Budget tables confirm the squeeze.
This is prioritisation of the NHS and selected social programmes, not a plan for broad private-sector growth.
The real-terms decline in the overall funding lines, combined with cuts to existing business-support programmes, underpins managed decline rather than recovery.
Economic activity in Wales is stagnating and payroll numbers are falling. High-quality public services rest on a thriving private sector. The declining public sector simply reflects the decline of the once-vibrant economy.
What must we do?
Business rates must be cut across the board.
The place to start is to cut government spending and waste so the multiplier can fall for every ratepayer, not just one subset. But solving this problem now is going to take bravery, imagination, and a rethink over what government prioritises.
A national @reformparty_uk government, working with a Reform government in Wales, will begin to deliver the change that is needed.
There is much that can be done. This draft budget is weak on what matters.
gov.wales/draft-budget-2027-…
lol
My immediate response to the Welsh Government's draft annual budget:
We've heard a great deal about this £28.2 billion Budget being a reset. A new Government, a new direction and, we're told, a new approach to public spending.
Well, I welcome any genuine attempt to get Wales moving in the right direction. Because, frankly, after years of economic underperformance under Labour, we desperately need one.
I also acknowledge the difficult financial position. The Government itself says resource funding is falling by 0.5 per cent in real terms next year, with capital funding facing an even greater squeeze over the coming years. If that's true, let me help by pointing out some areas of the Budget to cut, so that we can protect frontline services.
The measure of this Budget isn't how many announcements Ministers can make. It's whether the decisions they take will leave Wales more prosperous, our public services stronger and taxpayers getting better value for money.
We only received the full Budget documents an hour or so ago, so our detailed scrutiny will follow, with amendments in the new year when we finally get to vote in plenary.
But today I want to focus on two straightforward questions.
Firstly, what is this Government doing to get the Welsh economy growing?
And secondly, what unnecessary spending is it prepared to stop to make that possible?
Firstly, infrastructure.
If we want a stronger economy, we need infrastructure that actually allows businesses to operate, people to travel and goods to move around Wales.
Take the M4 relief road. Originally proposed in the early 1990s. Millions spent on planning. And then scrapped.
Despite some weird ideas about closing junctions, we all know the best solution is to build the relief road. Just accept it and do it. It will help economic activity, business growth, workers' travel and tourism in Wales's largest economic zone.
And on the subject of roads, the default 20mph speed limit needs to be abolished. Even the Welsh Government's own impact assessment estimates that longer journey times could cost the Welsh economy as much as £8.9 billion over 30 years.
And then there's the third Menai crossing.
I challenged the Minister on this only last month. The estimated cost was £670 million, yet the funding discussed amounted to just £20 million to £25 million over five years, largely for preparatory work.
So I'll ask the Minister again: where is the funded plan to actually build the crossing?
We cannot keep announcing projects, spending money on plans and then quietly shelving them when the bill arrives.
Secondly, business rates.
I welcome genuine relief for our struggling pubs, hospitality venues and high streets.
But the Welsh Government's proposed 30 per cent reduction for smaller premises is being funded by increasing the multiplier on the highest-value business properties.
In other words, it gives relief to one group of employers while increasing costs for another – and this is serious. These are large employers in Wales. By driving up business rates for bigger companies, you will be holding back the economy, job creation and wage growth for workers.
Last month, I asked the Minister to publish a proper assessment of the potential impact on jobs at those larger businesses. I didn't get a yes-or-no answer.
Reform also tried, on various committees in this Senedd, to scrutinise the business rates legislation, but the administration stepped in and told us no.
So I'll ask again today: will the Government publish a full jobs impact assessment before these business rate changes are approved?
We should be lowering business rates for all Welsh businesses, not simply moving the burden around.
And Ministers must consider the cumulative impact of the visitor levy, business taxation and costly environmental requirements on businesses already struggling to remain competitive.
Thirdly, our frontline public services.
The NHS continues to be in a dire financial situation – an issue I highlighted in the Express a few weeks ago. Audit Wales found that NHS Wales is hundreds of millions of pounds in the red, that six of the seven health boards failed in their legal duty to balance the books, and that there is no credible plan to turn this around.
In August, just 59.9 per cent of patients starting cancer treatment did so within 62 days, against a Government target of 75 per cent.
And one of your big campaign pledges was to lower NHS waiting lists, but they continue to rise.
We need sustainable and efficient spending in NHS Wales, not another annual cycle of financial bailouts.
We must do more to train doctors, nurses and midwives, fund their placements, and ensure that newly qualified staff can actually find jobs here, rather than just bringing in staff from abroad.
Education is equally important to our economic future.
The latest PISA results show Wales can't even match Turkey, let alone England.
That is not the foundation of a competitive economy.
Our schools need better outcomes, proper support for additional learning needs and a funding settlement that reflects the pressures they're under.
And local government is no different.
The Welsh Local Government Association estimates councils face £554 million of financial pressures next year.
But that cannot become an automatic justification for ever-higher council tax. We need serious efficiencies and sensible financial plans to live within our means.
Fourthly, we need to confront the underlying economic problem.
New research from the Adam Smith Institute estimates that, in Wales, £1.88 is spent on welfare for every £1 raised from workers' income tax and National Insurance.
Now, that includes pensions and benefits largely controlled by Westminster, and it isn't a measure of Wales's entire public finances. But it shows Wales needs more people in well-paid work, more successful businesses and a stronger tax base.
Wales cannot build long-term prosperity simply by managing economic decline. We have to reverse it.
That brings me to the other side of this Budget.
Because it is not enough for Ministers to tell us what they want to spend money on.
They must also tell us what they are prepared to stop funding.
Firstly, our public bodies and quangos.
This isn't just a criticism from Reform.
Earlier this year, the then Auditor General for Wales, Adrian Crompton, warned that the complexity of our public bodies had produced a system that was fragmented, slow-moving and burdened by overlapping responsibilities.
He was right.
We need an urgent review of duplication across public bodies, partnerships and administration, with clear savings targets and proper accountability.
The latest published figures, for 2024-25, show that the Welsh Government awarded over £2.5 billion in grants to Welsh Government Sponsored Bodies, third sector organisations and NGOs. But that isn't everything.
We don't know the total cost, because not enough information is published to break it down easily.
Over £500 million is reportedly given to the third sector and media organisations. For example, the biased political activists masquerading as a media outlet, Nation Cymru, have managed to receive over £250,000 since 2020.
The Welsh state needs to be cut down, with savings and efficiencies aggressively sought. Convenient political allies are being propped up by taxpayers' cash. We can't go on wasting billions of pounds that should be spent on frontline public services.
Secondly, constitutional spending.
The Government has now established another National Commission to examine Wales's constitutional future, reportedly at a cost of £500,000 a year. More waste of taxpayers' money that should be used for frontline public services.
And at the same time, its Programme for Government explicitly seeks the power to determine the process for an independence referendum, alongside further devolution of policing, justice and welfare.
Whenever my colleagues or I ask for costed plans for more devolution, you can never give us any forecasts. You want more without having any idea of the cost or how you'd implement it.
You are failing to make the powers you already have work well, never mind adding more.
The same test should apply to Welsh Government programmes such as the Nation of Sanctuary.
Since 2019, the Welsh Government has spent or allocated approximately £75 million through its Nation of Sanctuary and related migration budgets. And in this 2027-28 draft Budget, you are still funding it.
The Nation of Sanctuary is a political choice. The Welsh Government's job is to help the people of Wales, not to encourage more illegal and legal migration to the UK using taxpayers' money – especially as, earlier this year, we heard a Home Office whistleblower claim that only 1 per cent of asylum pleas are genuine.
And finally, international spending.
This is an area Reform has consistently challenged.
Foreign aid and international activity are not devolved powers. You shouldn't be wasting Welsh taxpayers' money abroad when we desperately need it here to help the people of Wales, and yet you are still funding these projects in the new Budget.
We at Reform are very glad that our campaign has paid off and that the ridiculous tree-planting project in Uganda – costing £350,000 this year, and supported by the Conservatives in the past – won't be renewed in March.
However, your Government's statement also seemed to suggest that this money will continue to be used for international spending rather than to help the people of Wales. Can you confirm that you will use this money to invest in Wales, rather than find another ridiculous foreign project to waste our money on?
Look at the projects I revealed in the Telegraph two weeks ago: over £300,000 spent this year alone on the small grants scheme in Africa.
Under that scheme, the Welsh Government spent £25,000 on disability-inclusive beekeeping in Uganda and Ghana, £21,000 on financial literacy for LGBTQ+ people in Uganda, and over £19,000 on radio phone-in shows between Ugandan and Welsh farmers to discuss climate change. An absolutely ridiculous waste of money.
Then there are the overseas offices.
Wales maintains 20 offices across 11 countries. Recent annual figures put their running costs at around £4.7 million, with a further £750,000 for activities.
That's nearly £5.5 million for the overseas network alone.
Add wider international engagement and international sustainable development, and the combined budget rises to over £9.2 million a year. And even that isn't the full picture of the cost.
The Welsh Government can't get things right at home, let alone crusade around the world like a colonial power trying to fix the world's problems.
You can't find £10 million for the Covid inquiry you promised bereaved Covid families before the election, but you can find well over £9 million for foreign aid projects and plush offices across the globe.
If I may turn to Plaid MS Elwyn Vaughan – have you got up to £10 million to waste?
And staying on the theme of international spending, let's talk about Taith, the Welsh Government's student exchange programme. It has received over £35 million since 2022.
It funds not just students and teachers from Wales to travel abroad but also foreign nationals to come to Wales, with Welsh taxpayers' money covering their travel costs, visa applications, accommodation in Wales and living expenses – to the tune of over £1.9 million since 2022.
Let's take a closer look at the individual projects taxpayers are funding through Taith.
£19,000 to send 10, quote, "marginalised Wrexham graffiti artists" to Barcelona to meet a Spanish graffiti "crew", and for three members of that "crew" to come to Wrexham for a, quote, "graffiti jam".
£25,000 to send "LGBTQ+ young leaders" to Canada to find out how they celebrate Pride, so they can "strengthen Pride activities" in Wales.
£1,600 to send a primary school teacher to look at "Islamic geometric/biomorphic patterns" in Turkey.
£16,000 to send "10 trade union activists" to Germany.
It is clear that Taith duplicates student exchange programmes at UK level, so Welsh taxpayers are paying twice for the same scheme. It's also clear that Taith has become politically and ideologically captured by mad DEI and identity politics. Why are Welsh taxpayers paying for this nonsense? It's time for Taith to go.
In conclusion, a credible Budget should help Welsh businesses grow, deliver the infrastructure we've been promised, support our NHS workforce and improve standards in our schools.
It should also be prepared to confront waste, duplication and spending that cannot demonstrate a clear benefit.
We have only just received these documents. There will be a great deal more to say once we've examined the details, and Reform will bring forward constructive amendments based on that scrutiny for next year's vote on the annual Budget.
We are prepared to work with Members across this Chamber when proposals genuinely put Wales first.
But constructive opposition does not mean providing the Government with a blank cheque.
If this really is a Budget of change, Minister, show us not just what you intend to spend, but what you're prepared to stop spending.
Because Wales cannot afford another four years of announcements without delivery.
Oh no.
A report on how Welsh Labour can regain support misinterpreted the polling data it used to analyse the party’s heavy defeat in May’s Senedd election, according to former Minister Lee Waters ✍️@ShiptonMartin wp.me/p8Mk4U-1xwm
5
272
Under the Labour Party in Wales you’ll feel more Welsh if you get cancer treatment faster.
Interesting report on where Welsh Labour go next welshlabour.wales/wp-content…
9
546
c) it’s a valid way for people to focus during a creative process.
I'm anti-smoking as a habit because of all the lung cancer, but I'm in favour of it on a societal level because a) it's hot and b) it's a good form of social intimacy to be able to ask someone if they have a light/cig. Not many other things you can randomly ask a stranger for.
2
179
Tomos Roberts-Young retweeted
Pretty evident from this that Welsh Labour is now a devosceptic party.
thenationalpulse.com/analysi…
My extended thoughts on massive demographic change in the UK can be found here.
“Simply put, the indigenous population of this country, White Britons, made Great Britain the way it is. People of all races have contributed since 1945 (and they deserve praise and gratitude for doing so), but British culture, its institutions and way of life, are overwhelmingly a product of its indigenous White British population. For that culture to be perpetuated from generation to generation, it is important to limit the number of people from other countries who come to live in the UK. If too many arrive, instead of assimilating into our way of life (which is entirely possible and has been achieved by millions of people of all races, including my own colleagues in Reform UK), they will bring with them their own way of life.”
1
2
159
Bloody Huguenots coming over from medieval France, erasing out culture.
Replying to @FuturistPartyGB
Very frustrating. I also say ‘white British’, not white. Don’t give a shit what colour you are, I care about the indigenous people of Great Britain remaining a majority in their own country, for reasons that I outline very briefly in the speech (you only get a minute) and at greater length in articles I’ve written.
2
10
643
Reform Wales leader Helen Jenner asked: “Is Reform a racist party?”
Jenner says: “No, half of my family is Filipino.”
Straight out of a sketch lmao.
It’s not been a good day for the doctrine of the Trinity or Christology on Twitter.
Glad I get my theology from Schleiermacher and not American culture wars
I'm amazed at the # of Christians who believe, since God took on the human form of a biological male, we can conclude that God the Father is eternally male.
Also amazed at the anger generated by pointing out this is not historic Christian teaching.
7
352




























