Pinned Tweet
I think I'm going to just start retweeting Public Health lies. PH is morally bankrupt, ideologically captured. Mostly just BS artists. If I can keep my nausea in check, I'll make it a mega-thread.
Exhibit #1:
If you think vaping will help you quit smoking, think again. People who use e-cigarettes to quit are 28% less successful than those who don’t.
spr.ly/6012J7Nsy
Wth?? Quickbooks switched to paying payroll taxes instead of the user initiating payment. All fine and good. But they're taking the money out before it's due!! Sometimes months to half a year in advance! (FUDA). That doesn't sound right. And there's no opt out. They're not giving us a choice.
2
69
Paul Bates retweeted
Over 10 yrs ago my asthma inhaler went generic and became cheap. But the govt said the propellant was bad for the environment, mandated a new type, and I was back to buying branded for $$$$. Recently that new type went generic as well. Cheap again! Yay! Except now the govt says this propellant is *also* unsafe, and will be banning it, forcing everyone to buy a (patented of course) newer more expensive type yet again. Funny how the timing works that drugs become “unsafe/environmentally bad” juuuust as the pharmaceutical patents run out. Very curious, that.
Paul Bates retweeted
The same result. Every. Single. Time. #NotAboutHealth
Another study, this time from Canada, finds that restricting vape flavours increases the sale of cigarettes. ideas.repec.org//p/umc/wpape…
Paul Bates retweeted
"Nicotine, isolated and dosed responsibly, behaves less like a vice and more like a mental aid." Well-written article devoid of the usual morl panic. A welcome rarity from @SpliceToday2022 splicetoday.com/pop-culture/…
Paul Bates retweeted
After 16 years, my @YouTube channel (GrimmGreen) was terminated today with no real explanation.
I’ve built my content around harm reduction, helping adult smokers quit, and advocating for science-based policies.
This feels like a huge mistake. If you believe in THR, free speech, and the mission we’ve been on, please help me get YouTube’s attention.
@TeamYouTube I’m asking for a real human to review my case.
I’ve never promoted anything illegal. I’ve never targeted youth. I’ve worked tirelessly to be a responsible voice in the vaping and harm reduction space. But like many creators in this space, it seems I’ve been swept up in an overly aggressive moderation wave.
Paul Bates retweeted
New Global Study Confirms It: Vaping Helps More Smokers Quit Than Any Other Method
mipod.com/blogs/mipodblog/ne…
Paul Bates retweeted
COP11 is coming and the EU still has to finalise its path forward. Let’s compare Sweden and Spain’s fight against smoking.
🇪🇸 Spain:
❌ Ban on flavours in e-cigarettes and nicotine pouches
❌ High taxes on smoke-free alternatives
❌ Smoking rate stagnant at 25.8% (down 15% since 2012)
🇸🇪 Sweden:
✅ Embraced smoke-free alternatives
✅ Harm-based taxation
✅ Lowest EU smoking rate at 5.3% (down 54% since 2012)
Paul Bates retweeted
Here is another video that @YouTube removed today for "medical misinformation". It's a video about a cancer study getting retracted.
It's literally a scientifically based video using data from @NIH , but @YouTubeCreators feels this science is "misinformation"
In this video i'm literally warning people about bad science that was retracted by the authors. How is that misinforming people?
pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/article…
Paul Bates retweeted
This comment from @dilanesper to @mattyglesias absolutely nails it. The tobacco wars never ended, the puritans just turned the guns in a different direction.
Paul Bates retweeted
Arthur Laffer, the economist who gave his name to the economic theory of the "Laffer curve", holds up Australia's tobacco taxation as a "perfect example of the extreme version of the Laffer Curve".
"It's not working at all."
abc.net.au/news/2025-10-14/i…
Paul Bates retweeted
New study added today thanks to @ArielleSelya and @jkelovuori. If anyone sees errors in my brief summaries, please let me know.
But we just don't know, right? No long-term data, right? Not enough evidence, right? (Only >10,000 scientific studies; they've only been used for 18 years now...)
Here are a few peer-reviewed academic (non-industry) scientific studies, many in very prestigious journals:
1) Cancer risk plummets when smokers switch to e-cigarettes
Excess Lifetime Cancer Risk (ELCR) drops >10,000-fold.
sciencedirect.com/science/ar…
A more conservative estimate found lifetime cancer risk drops 99.5% (0.5% risk would be difficult to measure; difficult to distinguish from “background noise”)
tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/conte…
Use of nicotine vapes significantly reduces exposure to a major pulmonary carcinogen, NNAL (results of 4-arm, parallel-group, randomized, controlled trial funded by US NIH and FDA)
thelancet.com/journals/lanre…
2) Cardiovascular health improves when smokers switch to ecigs
According to the American Heart Association, smokers who switch to nicotine vaping have a 7-fold lower risk of stroke; their heart health biomarkers are indistinguishable from never-smokers; and they have a 30%-40% lower risk of cardiovascular events than people who continue to smoke.
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/article…
ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/…
ahajournals.org/doi/pdf/10.1…
Systematic review and meta-analysis of 63 studies: “...short-to-medium-term transition from cigarettes to e-cigarettes may improve blood flow and blood pressure... There is lack of evidence supporting any association of e-cigarette use with cardiovascular diseases and cardiac dysfunction or remodelling." Exclusive vapers had no significant differences in heart rate (HR) or blood pressure (BP) compared with non-users, and lower HR and BP than smokers.
heart.bmj.com/content/early/…
They “experienced positive cardiovascular impact after both a 3- and 6-month period” including significant improvement in flow-mediated dilation, peak cutaneous vascular conductance responses to acetylcholine and sodium nitroprusside, and mean arterial pressure. These benefits were exactly the same for e-cigarettes and NRTs.
bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.co…
“We did not find a significant difference in the cardiovascular risk of exclusive e-cigarette use compared with nonuse of cigarettes and e-cigarettes.” [i.e., nicotine vapers’ cardiovascular risk is indistinguishable from non-smokers and non-vapers.] Study funded by NIH & FDA.
ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/…
Exclusive use of nicotine vapes (“e-cigarettes”) was not associated with a statistically significant increased risk of self-reported incidents of diagnosed cardiovascular disease over a 5-year period, whereas exclusive cigarette smoking is.
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3590…; academic.oup.com/ntr/advance…
Smoking cessation showed positive cardiovascular impact within 3 days, and the effects did not differ between nicotine-containing e-cigarettes and nicotine replacement therapies (e.g., nicotine patch or nicotine gum).
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3590…; and academic.oup.com/ntr/advance…
1,179 heart attack patients followed for 41.7 months. 710 participants who smoked at baseline, but switched to e-cigarettes over the next year, had 57% lower odds of subsequent major adverse cardiovascular events compared to those who continued smoking (11.4% vs. 22.3%).
sciencedirect.com/science/ar…
Systolic and diastolic blood pressure, and blood pressure control, improve, and significant weight gains associated with cold turkey smoking cessation do not occur.
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2784…
Blood vessel health improves significantly
jacc.org/doi/10.1016/j.jacc.…
nature.com/articles/s41569-0…
sciencedirect.com/science/ar…
sciencedirect.com/science/ar…
3) Lung health improves when smokers switch to e-cigarettes
Lung cilia recover full function (these cilia remove solid particulates, bacteria and fungal spores from healthy lungs; cigarettes damage lung cilia function).
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/article…
Respiratory tract infections drop dramatically
dspace.stir.ac.uk/bitstream/…
Longitudinal analysis of the Population Assessment of Tobacco and Health (PATH) Study, an observational cohort study that surveyed 5,653 US adults ≥18 years, shows “Switching completely from past 30-day use of cigarettes to e-cigarettes had short-term beneficial associations with functionally important respiratory symptoms similar to quitting tobacco completely.”
sciencedirect.com/science/ar…
thelancet.com/journals/eclin…
They have 20% less cough and 30% less phlegm than smokers who quit with nicotine patches or gum.
nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/ne…
Data from 9,000 adults aged ≥ 16 years: “Exclusive e-cigarette use was not associated with higher odds of wheezing compared with never-use, and it was linked to substantially lower odds than exclusive cigarette smoking.”
link.springer.com/article/10…
Analysis of 19,000 people found 65% of smokers with asthma and 76% of smokers with COPD reported improvement in respiratory symptoms after switching to ecigs.
mdpi.com/1660-4601/11/4/4356…
COPD smokers’ lung health and quality of life improve dramatically (participants followed for 5 years). “COPD exacerbations were reduced by approximately 50% in patients who stopped or considerably reduced their smoking consumption after switching to vaping.”
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/article…
Asthmatic smokers experience “Significant improvement in asthma control and quality of life”
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3196…
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2701…
mdpi.com/1660-4601/11/5/4965
discoverymedicine.com/Riccar…
mdpi.com/1660-4601/19/15/905…
What about never-smokers who vape nicotine?
'No detectable changes in lung health' of never-smokers who vaped nicotine for up to 4 years
nature.com/articles/s41598-0…
Studies that looked at both cardiovascular and lung health:
2022 review by University of Michigan researchers: When smokers switch, risk of acute cardiopulmonary events drops rapidly; long-term use leads to lung health benefits, especially among asthmatic and COPD smokers. No cancer risk found.
mdpi.com/1660-4601/19/15/905…
E-cigarette users who never smoked, followed for 3.5 years: No significant health changes in blood pressure, heart rate, body weight, lung function, respiratory symptoms, exhaled breath nitric oxide or carbon monoxide; and “no pathological findings could be identified on high-resolution computed tomography of the lungs, and no respiratory symptoms were consistently reported in the e-cigarette user group.”
nature.com/articles/s41598-0…
E-cigarette users’ health biomarkers are indistinguishable from never-smokers. Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) are Harmful or Potentially Harmful Substances (HPHS) measured at high levels in smokers. “When compared with people who never smoked, E-cigarette smokers [sic] had similar blood concentrations of VOCs.”
archpublichealth.biomedcentr…
Paul Bates retweeted
Cancer risk from e-cigarettes > 50 000 (thousand) fold lower than smoking
"57,000-fold"
ecigarette-research.org/rese…
Paul Bates retweeted
If you are following the War on Vaping, a crucial battle just broke out in the prestigious pages of @NTR_Journal. It features the editor-in-chief vs. Bloomberg's top scientist - with a tag-in off the top rope by the intrepid @Clive_Bates.
1/🪡
Paul Bates retweeted
Of all places to find a growing citizens’ rebellion against the nanny state, who’d guess it’s happening in woke Denver?
Take note — if Denverites can claw back a little freedom from their elite, it can happen in your city too. #copolitics
In this city of 70 breweries, 2,000 liquor establishments, some 300 cannabis dispensaries and now mushroom clinics, it was pure poetry when the city council and Mayor Mike Johnston passed a ban on adults buying flavored tobacco and nicotine products, you know, for the kids.
A hint of cherry in your beer — sure. Peach-infused vodka — bring it on! Any bit of flavor in the product you’re using to help you quit smoking — a perversion that must be stamped out.
I imagine the city council members who voted to disempower people from their own bodily autonomy also spout “my body, my choice.”
The cognitive dissonance required for this type of selective maternalistic fascism is monumental. After all, those elite took away the personal decisions of 730,000 Denverites because, well, they know what’s right for others.
What they don’t say aloud, but we hear perfectly, is, “your body, our choice.” And constituents are finding that offensive.
Pushing back at the ballot
Fortunately, some feisty business owners who didn’t appreciate potentially watching their shop be put out of business as pot shops spring up around them decided to do something. They delivered more than 17,000 signatures to repeal this bit of intolerance. And they’re starting to get some interesting allies.
Referendum 310 on the Denver ballot this fall repeals the ban on new smoking cessation products like Zyn and old favorites like Swisher Sweets cigars, which back in my day had to be smoked by every grandfather under penalty of law. Kids today just can’t get enough of them (if not obvious, that’s sarcasm).
Some progressives are understanding woke nannyism is driving people away from the Democratic Party.
Progressive leader Deep Singh Badhesha announced on X, “After a fight, the Denver Democrats will officially take no position on the flavored tobacco ban. Let’s stop nanny state politics that alienate working class voters and protect much needed revenue. This kind of government overreach is exactly what turns voters off.”
Democratic state Sen. Nick Hinrichsen piled on, “Democrats need to take a page out of the libertarian playbook. Adult choices that have no non-consenting third-party impact are never the government’s damn business. Ever.”
Have progressives decided they no longer care about children, realizing pre-teens just look cool with lit cigarettes dandling from their little mouths?
Or have they recognized many of their African-American constituents like menthols, which are now contraband? Or maybe they’ve noticed the large number of black and Hispanic voters who are growing tired of woke policies and voted for President Donald Trump.
In any event, it’s refreshing to see progressives stand up for personal liberty — just like it’s disappointing when conservatives join the nanny left and “for the children” prohibit adults from buying Swisher Sweets cigars.
Team nanny falling short
Also encouraging is the pro-freedom team is outraising “team nanny” in campaign contributions. Tobacco and vape-shop owners losing their businesses to these bans are putting in the most money, followed by the companies that make the products.
The committee fighting to keep the ban is “Yes for Denver Kids,” which as far as I can tell has no kids in it, only aspiring babysitters. They hide behind kids, but — like tobacco, booze, cannabis and mushrooms — it’s already illegal to sell nicotine products to kids.
They say the reason to ban nicotine products to everyone at every age is sometimes these products have found their way into young people’s hands. Fortunately booze, tobacco, pot and mushrooms never find their respective ways into young people’s hands. We know that hasn’t happened because if it did city council would quickly ban those products too. They are that consistent and care that much about kids.
Most of the money for team nanny comes from Tobacco-Free Kids Action Fund (even though kids can’t buy tobacco), Kaiser Permanente and nanny ultra-funder Michael Bloomberg, who also outlawed large sodas when he was mayor of New York.
So, just what is the difference between Michael Bloomberg and Robert F. Kennedy Jr.? Both have strongly held and controversial beliefs on public health policy. But though RFK Jr. says you shouldn’t take Tylenol, he hasn’t banned it.
Election night we’ll see if Colorado’s deepest-blue voters tell their elite they can make their own decisions.
Paul Bates retweeted
The Chinese vape products are not all crap; far from it. Many of these products are legal, well-engineered, and popular in other jurisdictions. A particularly damaging influence of @FDATobacco is its effect on lawful American innovation. It is impossible for law-abiding vape companies to be responsive to changing consumer tastes if it takes five years to authorise a product and FDA looks like it will only authorise a very narrow range of unappealing designs. The illicit products come from Chinese companies where lightening speed innovation is everything. If they avoid FDA they can have highly competitive, low cost innovations in the (illicit) market within days, not years. One further effect is that FDA ties up scientific, engineering and design resources on compliance with its super -burdensome PMTA process. In Shenzhen, those technical and human resources can go into innovation. The original Juul product finally authorised by FDA in July 2025 was first on the market in 2015. The Juul 2 is still not authorised in the US, but that went on the market in the UK in 2021.
Paul Bates retweeted
Attention vape fam 🚨 we are putting together a list of businesses that have been forced to shut down due to unclear regulations and government overreach. If you know of any stores, shops, distributors, etc. that have closed in the past 12 months, please help by sharing their information.
docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1F…
Paul Bates retweeted
Imagine if you could "smoke less". @FDATobacco helped finance it. Public health encouraged, then endorses it. Look very carefully at the graphic on the right.
You've got 60 seconds.
Paul Bates retweeted
An open letter to @realDonaldTrump @POTUS
"FDA Overreach Is Killing Small Businesses You Promised to Protect."
"We urge you to hold FDA accountable, demand a fair and workable regulatory framework, and stand up for the tens of thousands of small businesses, workers, and millions of adult consumers who rely on this industry as an alternative to deadly combustible tobacco."
resist.bot/petitions/PTWPUK?…
Paul Bates retweeted
Replying to @phil_w888
Dear Tobacco Control researchers:
What Phil said, and 👇
xitter.gq/Vapingit/status/191436…
How are those 480,000 'smoking related' deaths compiled? @BrentStafford ASKS; Dr. @BradRodu SPEAKS of those '480k' numbers - NO one - can find the source and answer to that #data?
Via @RegWatchCanada
Full link Jul 22, 2022: youtu.be/v2tXjjaEIlM?si=tLaL…


























